← All articles

Total current articles · 5,098

Lieberman Plan

Published

01In brief

Lieberman Plan is a proposal by Avigdor Lieberman to exchange Arab-populated territory inside Israel for Jewish settlement areas in the West Bank — known by its original, indigenous Jewish name of Judea and Samaria — as part of an Israeli-Palestinian agreement. Presented in May 2004, it centered on changing sovereignty over populated areas rather than requiring residents to move. At the United Nations General Assembly on September 28, 2010, Lieberman explained, “I am not speaking about moving populations, but rather about moving borders to better reflect demographic realities.” Its principal focus was the Triangle and Wadi Ara, whose residents would become citizens of a Palestinian state under formulations allowing them to remain in their homes; the proposal generated opposition over citizenship, consent, and its demographic purpose.

02Overview

The proposal links Israeli sovereignty over Jewish settlements in Judea and Samaria to Palestinian sovereignty over predominantly Arab communities inside Israel, particularly the Triangle and Wadi Ara.[1] Lieberman presented it as a redrawing of borders and jurisdiction rather than the physical relocation of residents.[2] Maintaining a Jewish majority in Israel was an explicit objective of Yisrael Beiteinu’s presentation of the proposal.[5]

The party’s stated alternative to land-for-peace was “peace for peace, land for land,” with an agreement addressing relations with Arab states and the status of Israeli Arabs as well as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.[3] In its 2019 platform, the populated-territories exchange formed part of a broader agreement with the Palestinians and Arab states, allowing Israeli Arabs who identified with the Palestinians to become citizens of a Palestinian state without leaving their homes.[3]

Citizenship was therefore central alongside territorial sovereignty. The 2019 platform said residents of the Triangle and Wadi Ara could become Palestinian citizens without moving, while people elsewhere in Israel could give up Israeli citizenship, move, and become citizens of a future Palestinian state, potentially with economic incentives.[3] Other accounts described loss of Israeli citizenship for those remaining under Palestinian rule or a choice between moving to Israel and receiving compensation.[5][6] Earlier formulations also encompassed Arab neighborhoods near Jerusalem and linked continued citizenship to an allegiance requirement.[7]

03Origins and History

Lieberman presented a plan for exchanging territory and population at a seminar in May 2004. It envisaged transferring adjoining Arab-populated areas to the Palestinian Authority in return for Israeli sovereignty over Jewish settlements and enclaves in Judea and Samaria.[1] That month, then-Transportation Minister Lieberman also publicly advocated transferring Israeli-Arab communities to the occupied territories.[8]

In a March 2006 interview, Lieberman described retaining settlement blocs while transferring Arab-Israeli towns, including Umm al-Fahm, to the Palestinian Authority.[9] He maintained that the proposal had international support, cited border changes elsewhere, and said it could be implemented without the affected Arab residents’ consent.[9] Henry Kissinger expressed support for the general idea of exchanging settlement blocs around Jerusalem for equivalent Israeli territory with substantial Arab populations, while critics regarded Lieberman’s proposal as an effort to remove Arab citizens from Israel.[9]

A 2007 document setting out Lieberman’s conditions for a permanent agreement called for territorial and population exchanges that would ensure an 80 percent Jewish majority in Israel.[10] It said borders should reflect historical, security, demographic, and geographic considerations, and that an agreement should secure international recognition of those borders and an end to mutual claims.[10] The document also required security and economic conditions to be addressed before permanent-status negotiations and rejected a Palestinian right of return to Israel.[10]

During 2009, Yisrael Beiteinu members advocated exchanging Arab communities inside Israel for Jewish settlements in the West Bank in media interviews and public gatherings.[11] By early 2010, the party’s position linked support for a Palestinian state to an exchange of Israeli Arabs and their territory for Jewish settlers and settlements; the proposed areas included Arab neighborhoods of Jerusalem.[7] Lieberman’s accompanying demand for a loyalty oath was expressed in the campaign slogan “no loyalty, no citizenship.”[7]

At the United Nations General Assembly on September 28, 2010, Lieberman argued that an “exchange of populated territory,” rather than “land-for-peace,” should guide a final-status agreement.[2] He distinguished changing borders to reflect demographic realities from physically moving populations.[2] Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said the speech had not been coordinated with him and that peace-process questions would be decided at the negotiating table, while Defense Minister Ehud Barak said it did not represent the government’s position.[2]

In January 2014, Lieberman said Yisrael Beiteinu would not support a comprehensive agreement unless it included exchanges of both territory and population.[12] Naming the Triangle and Wadi Ara, he said residents would not be expelled from their homes or dispossessed, but would come under full Palestinian sovereignty and become Palestinian citizens.[12] Later that year, the party’s document “Going Against the Stream – Yisrael Beiteinu’s Vision” placed the exchange within a broader Regional Peace Plan involving Arab states, Palestinians, and Arab citizens of Israel.[13]

The November 2014 document proposed economic incentives for Israeli Arabs who identified as Palestinian to relinquish Israeli citizenship and become citizens of a future Palestinian state.[13] Lieberman’s presentation extended that option beyond the exchange areas, naming Jaffa and Acre, and argued that Israel should be willing to relinquish the idea of a Greater Israel for a comprehensive agreement with the Arab world.[13][14]

Lieberman reiterated support for a two-state solution and territorial and population exchanges in an October 2016 interview, attributing the underlying problem to Palestinian leadership and extremism rather than Jerusalem.[15] In 2018, he renewed his call to transfer jurisdiction over Triangle towns after the funeral in Umm al-Fahm of Ahmed Muhammad Mahameed, who had been shot dead while attempting to stab an officer in Jerusalem; Lieberman said the attendance and chants made his exchange proposal “more relevant than ever.”[16]

The populated-territories principle remained in Yisrael Beiteinu’s 2019 platform, which specifically named the Triangle and Wadi Ara and included possible economic incentives for people elsewhere in Israel who chose Palestinian citizenship.[3] In 2020, Lieberman claimed that the Trump peace plan had adopted his 2004 proposal for territorial and population exchanges.[17] He also reiterated the importance of populated-area swaps, distinguished border changes from “transfer,” and said concessions in Jerusalem would require a national referendum and special legislation supported by a two-thirds majority.[18]

04Proposed Territorial and Citizenship Arrangements

The Triangle, including Umm al-Fahm, was the principal area proposed for transfer to Palestinian sovereignty.[19] Accounts of the 2004 proposal named Umm al-Fahm, Baqa al-Gharbiyye, Tayibe, and Kafr Qasim, together with Aram and Jabal al-Mukaber near East Jerusalem, in return for Israeli sovereignty over Jewish settlements and enclaves in Judea and Samaria.[1]

A 2020 Ynet comparison distinguished those terms from features it attributed to the later Trump peace plan. Its broader ten-town Triangle list, proposed western Negev areas linked to the Gaza Strip, Israeli sovereignty over the Jordan Valley, and projections covering approximately 97 percent of Israelis and Palestinians in the West Bank were presented as elements of the Trump plan, not as direct quotations of Lieberman’s 2004 proposal.[1] The comparison separately quoted Lieberman’s earlier rejection of territorial continuity for a proposed Palestinian entity.[1]

Jerusalem received separate treatment in Lieberman’s 2007 document, which called for the “Holy Basin” to remain under full Israeli sovereignty with freedom of worship.[10] Its stated boundaries extended to the Mount of Olives and Mount Scopus in the east, Sheikh Jarrah in the north, and Silwan and Mount Zion in the south.[10] The document also applied the exchange principle to refugee camps and villages near Jerusalem.[10]

The 2019 Yisrael Beiteinu platform said residents of the Triangle and Wadi Ara could become Palestinian citizens without leaving their homes.[3] For Arab citizens elsewhere in Israel who identified with the Palestinians, it described relinquishing Israeli citizenship, moving, and becoming citizens of a future Palestinian state, potentially encouraged by economic incentives.[3] A separate 2019 overview described residents in the exchange area as choosing between moving to Israel or receiving compensation and losing Israeli citizenship.[6]

Other formulations stated that a citizen choosing to live under Palestinian rule would lose Israeli citizenship or linked continued citizenship to moving inside Israel’s new borders and swearing allegiance.[5] The differing accounts reflect changes or variations in how the proposal’s citizenship arrangements were presented over time.

Demographic estimates depended on which communities were included. A calculation using August 2010 population figures estimated that a Triangle exchange incorporating Arab towns but excluding Israeli towns would affect 218,865 people.[19] This represented 14.07 percent of Israel’s Arab population and 2.87 percent of its total population, reducing the Arab share from 20.40 percent to 18.04 percent and changing the Jewish-to-Arab ratio from 3.7:1 to 4.3:1.[19]

A separate scenario that included East Jerusalem Arabs increased the population affected to 482,365 and reduced the Arab share to 15.02 percent; most East Jerusalem Arabs were not Israeli citizens.[19] A 2014 description estimated the Triangle’s population at approximately 300,000, while Lieberman himself said in a 2010 interview that his proposal would mean “at least half” of Israel’s Arab citizens would no longer be part of the state.[20][21]

Physical geography also affected potential boundaries. Excluding Arab towns north of Route 65 could substantially reduce the population included, but the road’s role as a key Israeli military artery complicated the arrangement.[22] The Jewish town of Katzir-Charish, with a population of a few thousand, lay in the middle of the Triangle, creating another question that Lieberman had not addressed.[22]

05Significance

The plan made the status of Arab citizens inside Israel part of Lieberman’s proposed resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, alongside settlement borders and relations with Arab states.[3] Its defining distinction was between exchanging unpopulated territory and exchanging territory together with jurisdiction over its inhabitants, connecting the location of a border to residents’ future citizenship.[19][3]

Demography was an explicit organizing principle: Lieberman’s 2007 conditions sought an 80 percent Jewish majority, while his later explanations presented border changes as a way to align national identity and state citizenship without requiring residents to leave their homes.[10][12] The party’s broader regional approach proposed addressing Israeli-Arab relations, Palestinian statehood, and peace with Arab countries within a single agreement rather than through a land-for-peace formula alone.[3][13]

The exchange remained part of Lieberman’s political program from its presentation in 2004 through the 2014 regional proposal and the party’s 2019 platform.[1][3] His 2020 claim that the Trump peace plan had adopted the proposal connected it to a later diplomatic initiative, while Ynet’s comparison identified similarities in territorial exchanges and rejection of a Palestinian right of return to Israel.[1][17]

06Controversies

Arab citizens overwhelmingly condemned community-exchange proposals in 2009, while Jewish opinion ranged from support to condemnation.[11] Residents interviewed in 2014 cited their wish to remain Israeli citizens, family and social ties across a prospective border, and concern about having to move if they rejected Palestinian citizenship.[4] President Shimon Peres opposed the proposal, stating, “Israel cannot deny citizenship to its citizens because they are Arabs.”[23]

Legal debate concerned transferring territory without residents’ consent and revoking citizenship. A Jerusalem Post report summarized the position of experts it consulted as permitting the state to relinquish territory but not to revoke citizenship.[24] Lieberman maintained in 2020 that the Foreign Ministry’s legal department had found border changes compatible with international law.[18]

No detailed plan had resolved the legal, social, and operational arrangements, including whether implementation depended on residents’ agreement.[25] In 2014, retired colonel Shaul Arieli judged the proposal politically unfeasible because of Palestinian and resident opposition and spatially limited by conditions created since 1949.[26] Government endorsement was also absent from Lieberman’s 2010 UN presentation, which Netanyahu’s office said had not been coordinated with the prime minister and Barak said did not represent government policy.[2]

Sources

  1. 1Ynet, План Трампа и план Либермана: найдите отличия, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  2. 2Ynetnews, PM's Office: Lieberman's UN speech not coordinated with Netanyahu, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  3. 3Jewish Virtual Library, Israel Political Parties: Yisrael Beiteinu, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  4. 4Ynetnews, Israeli Arabs: We don't want to be part of Palestinian state, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  5. 5Ynet, Avigdor Lieberman, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  6. 6Mako, 2019 Elections: A Political Solution to the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  7. 7EveryCRSReport, CRS, Israel: Background and Relations with the United States, January 2010, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  8. 8U.S. Department of State, Israel and the occupied territories, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  9. 9Ynetnews, Lieberman: I have international support, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  10. 10Ynet, The Lieberman Document: NATO in the Territories and Population Exchanges, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  11. 11U.S. Department of State, Israel and the occupied territories, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  12. 12Ynet, Lieberman: We Will Oppose an Agreement Without Land Swaps, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  13. 13Ynetnews, Lieberman's peace plan woos centrists: Regional peace is possible, even at expense of Greater Israel, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  14. 14Ynet, The Lieberman Plan: “The Unity of the People Is More Important Than the Unity of the Land”, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  15. 15Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, October 10–26, 2016, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  16. 16The Times of Israel, Liberman Renews Umm al-Fahm Exchange Call, 2018, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  17. 17Ynet, Blue and White: A Good Plan; Bennett: We Will Not Allow a Palestinian State, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  18. 18Institute for National Security Studies, Liberman: Arab States are Crucial in any Agreement, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  19. 19Institute for National Security Studies, Imagining the Border, David Makovsky, pp. 3–11, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  20. 20EveryCRSReport, CRS, Israel: Background and U.S. Relations, July 2014, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  21. 21Ynetnews, Lieberman depicts doctrine to Newsweek, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  22. 22Institute for National Security Studies, Imagining the Border, David Makovsky, pp. 24–30, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  23. 23Ynetnews, Lieberman: Arabs who want to remain Israeli are suddenly 'lovers of Zion', accessed on November 5, 2026.
  24. 24The Jerusalem Post, Lieberman's land swap plan illegal, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  25. 25Institute for National Security Studies, Integrating the Arab-Palestinian Minority in Israeli Society, accessed on November 5, 2026.
  26. 26Ynet, Land Swaps? “Not Feasible, Not Realistic”, accessed on November 5, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What is the Lieberman Plan?

    The Lieberman Plan is a proposal by Avigdor Lieberman to exchange Arab-populated territory inside Israel for Jewish settlement areas in the West Bank as part of an Israeli-Palestinian agreement. Presented in May 2004, it focused on changing borders and sovereignty rather than physically relocating residents. Its principal focus was the Triangle and Wadi Ara, whose residents could become citizens of a Palestinian state while remaining in their homes.

  • How did the Lieberman Plan address citizenship for residents of the Triangle and Wadi Ara?

    The 2019 Yisrael Beiteinu platform said residents of the Triangle and Wadi Ara could become Palestinian citizens without leaving their homes. Other accounts described different arrangements, including losing Israeli citizenship under Palestinian rule or choosing between moving to Israel and receiving compensation. Citizenship terms varied across the proposal’s different formulations.

  • Which areas did the Lieberman Plan propose exchanging?

    The Triangle, including Umm al-Fahm, was the principal area proposed for transfer to Palestinian sovereignty. Accounts of the 2004 proposal also named Baqa al-Gharbiyye, Tayibe, and Kafr Qasim, as well as Aram and Jabal al-Mukaber near East Jerusalem. The exchange was proposed in return for Israeli sovereignty over Jewish settlements and enclaves in Judea and Samaria.

  • What demographic goal did the Lieberman Plan set?

    A 2007 document setting out Lieberman’s conditions for a permanent agreement called for territorial and population exchanges that would ensure an 80 percent Jewish majority in Israel. Maintaining a Jewish majority was also an explicit objective of Yisrael Beiteinu’s presentation of the proposal.

  • Why was the Lieberman Plan controversial?

    The Lieberman Plan drew opposition over citizenship, residents’ consent, and its demographic purpose. Arab citizens overwhelmingly condemned community-exchange proposals in 2009, and residents interviewed in 2014 cited their desire to remain Israeli citizens, family and social ties, and concerns about having to move. Legal debate also focused on transferring territory without residents’ consent and revoking citizenship.

  • Did the Israeli government support the Lieberman Plan?

    Lieberman’s 2010 United Nations presentation did not represent the Israeli government’s position. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said the speech had not been coordinated with him and that peace-process questions would be decided at the negotiating table; Defense Minister Ehud Barak also said it did not represent government policy.