← All articles

Total current articles · 5,240

Holy See–Palestine Relations

Published

01In brief

Holy See–Palestine relations is the bilateral relationship linking the Holy See and Palestinian representatives, encompassing diplomatic recognition, agreements concerning the Catholic Church, and efforts toward Israeli-Palestinian peace. In June 2014, Pope Francis brought the Israeli and Palestinian presidents together for prayer at the Vatican, while explaining that the initiative sought to encourage renewed negotiations rather than serve as mediation. Relations developed from official contacts with the Palestine Liberation Organization into a Comprehensive Agreement signed with the State of Palestine in June 2015. Their principal themes include religious freedom, the protection of Christian communities and holy places, Palestinian statehood, and a negotiated peace with Israel.

02Overview

The Comprehensive Agreement signed on June 26, 2015, concerns essential aspects of the Catholic Church’s life and activity in Palestine and shifted the Holy See’s bilateral relationship from the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) to the State of Palestine.[5] The relationship therefore combines questions about the Church’s practical position with the broader diplomatic question of Palestinian statehood.[5] The Holy See possesses the status of a sovereign juridical entity under international law, including the capacity to conclude treaties and exchange diplomatic representatives.[6]

Preserving Christianity and a Christian presence in the Holy Land has been a central concern of the Holy See’s Middle East diplomacy since the Second Vatican Council, alongside peace with justice between Israel and the Palestinians.[4] Its wider regional concerns have also included maintaining Lebanon as an example of Christian-Muslim coexistence.[4] Within the Holy Land, these priorities have encompassed access to Catholic holy places, their upkeep, the sanctity of their surroundings, and the circumstances of Christian communities.[7]

Relations with Palestinian representatives have developed alongside, rather than in place of, relations with Israel.[8][9] Negotiations with Israel, Jordan, and the PLO formed parallel strands of Holy See diplomacy, with progress in relations with Israel understood as intertwined with the Israeli-Palestinian peace process.[9] The resulting agreements address different counterparts and legal settings: the Fundamental Agreement with Israel dates from 1993, while the Basic Agreement with the PLO dates from 2000.[8][1]

03Origins and History

In 1949, the Holy See favored the complete internationalization of Jerusalem, its environs, and the holy places in Palestine as a means of securing lasting peace.[10] Israeli Foreign Minister Moshe Sharett opposed internationalization that would place roughly 100,000 Jews living in Jerusalem’s New City outside Israel, and proposed alternatives involving international supervision of holy places and guaranteed free access.[10] By 2000, the Holy See’s policy had shifted from support for Jerusalem as an independent entity, or corpus separatum, toward international guarantees for the holy places.[7]

The Holy See signed its Fundamental Agreement with Israel on December 30, 1993, following the Rabin-Arafat meeting at the White House.[8] It agreed to exchange ambassadors after the May 4, 1994, Cairo Agreement between Israel and the PLO, and a further accord in 1997 addressed the juridical status of the Church and Catholic institutions in Israel.[8] These developments supplied the parallel Israeli context for the Holy See’s emerging formal arrangements with Palestinian representatives.[8][9]

Official relations with the PLO began in October 1994, with the organization identified as the representative of the Palestinian people.[1] The preamble of the subsequent Basic Agreement dates their establishment to October 26, 1994, and describes the PLO as acting for the benefit of and on behalf of the Palestinian Authority.[1] A joint commission established in January 1998 began negotiations on a pact concerning the Catholic Church and Christian communities in the Holy Land.[9]

In February 2000, Vatican diplomat Celestino Migliore and Palestinian counterpart Emile Jarjouri signed the Basic Agreement between the Holy See and the PLO.[11] It called for a peaceful solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that would realize the Palestinian people’s “inalienable national legitimate rights and aspirations.”[1] Its preamble connected a just and comprehensive regional peace to negotiations based on international law and relevant United Nations and Security Council resolutions.[1]

During his March 2000 Holy Land visit, Pope John Paul II met Yasser Arafat in Bethlehem and presented him with fourteen seashells, explaining their connection to the fourteen Stations of the Cross and the Passion of the Palestinians.[12] In the same period, Palestinian minister of international cooperation Nabil Sha’ath said Vatican officials had told him that the Holy See would recognize an independent Palestinian state, although it would be neither the first nor the last to do so.[11] John Paul II and his successor Benedict XVI called for justice for Palestinians and respect for UN Security Council Resolution 242.[11]

In Bethlehem in May 2009, Benedict XVI stated: “The Holy See supports the right of your people to a sovereign Palestinian homeland in the land of your forefathers, secure and at peace with its neighbors, within internationally recognized borders.”[13] He called on the international community to work toward a solution and urged Palestinian youth to resist violence and terrorism.[13] Archbishop Dominique Mamberti reiterated support for a two-state solution in September 2011.[11]

In November 2012, the UN General Assembly changed Palestine’s observer designation from an “entity” to a “nonmember state.”[14] This did not make Palestine a UN member or give it the right to vote or call for a vote in the General Assembly.[14] The Holy See welcomed the decision and functionally dealt with Palestine as a state after that change.[5][14] Its use of the designation “Palestine” in bilateral dealings began around 2012.[5]

On May 25, 2014, Pope Francis met Mahmoud Abbas in Bethlehem, with the Vatican itinerary identifying Abbas as president of the “State of Palestine.”[15] Francis visited the Palestinian Authority before Israel, the first pope to follow that sequence, and called for peace based on recognition of two states’ right to exist within internationally recognized borders.[15] The itinerary also described Bethlehem as being in the State of Palestine, terminology Israel rejected.[16]

Francis invited Abbas and Israeli President Shimon Peres to the Vatican for a joint prayer meeting, held in June 2014.[3][17] American-led peace talks had foundered in April, and Francis explained that the gathering was intended to create an atmosphere favorable to renewed talks rather than mediate between the parties.[3] Like John Paul II, he made efforts to restart the Israeli-Palestinian peace process a priority.[17]

The Holy See and the State of Palestine signed their Comprehensive Agreement on June 26, 2015.[5] Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi described the development as recognition that the state existed, while Archbishop Paul Gallagher expressed hope that the agreement would provide a “stimulus to bringing a definitive end to the longstanding Palestinian-Israeli conflict.”[5][18] The agreement concerned the Catholic Church’s life and activity as well as the upgraded bilateral relationship.[5]

The agreement entered into force after the parties notified each other that the necessary procedural requirements had been fulfilled; its entry into force was reported on January 2, 2016.[19] A Palestinian embassy officially opened at the Vatican in January 2017.[2] Mahmoud Abbas attended the inauguration.[20] Francis had also met Abbas during the 2014 Holy Land visit and again in 2015.[20]

Diplomatic engagement continued under Pope Leo XIV, who met Abbas in person for the first time on November 6, 2025.[21] Their discussions addressed assistance for Gaza’s civilian population and pursuit of a two-state solution.[21] The visit marked the tenth anniversary of the Comprehensive Agreement, which governs relations between the Holy See and the State of Palestine and Church activity in Palestinian Authority territories.[21]

04Practice and Application

Article 1 of the 2000 Basic Agreement commits the PLO to freedom of religion and conscience, while affirming the Catholic Church’s support for that right and respect for adherents of other religions.[1] Article 2 sets out cooperation on human rights, opposition to discrimination and threats to human life and dignity, and the promotion of understanding between communities.[1] It also commits the parties to encouraging interreligious dialogue.[1]

The agreement makes equality under Palestinian law a practical component of the relationship.[1] The PLO undertakes to protect citizens’ human and civil rights without discrimination based on religion or belief.[1] It also recognizes the Church’s freedom to perform spiritual, religious, charitable, educational, and cultural functions, making the agreement relevant to activities extending beyond worship alone.[1]

Separate provisions concern the Church’s institutional and legal position.[1] The agreement recognizes Church rights in economic, legal, and fiscal matters, to be exercised in harmony with the rights of Palestinian authorities, and calls for legal recognition of the Church and canonical legal persons.[1] It further requires maintenance of the Status Quo in Christian holy places wherever that arrangement applies.[1]

Implementation rests partly on a bilateral permanent working commission charged with proposing ways to address the agreement’s provisions.[1] Disagreements about interpretation or application are to be resolved through mutual consultation, and the agreement states that its provisions do not prejudice existing agreements between either party and another party.[1] Unlike the later Comprehensive Agreement’s notification process, the Basic Agreement provided for entry into force upon signature.[1][19]

Jerusalem receives particular attention in the Basic Agreement’s preamble, which presents an equitable solution for the city as fundamental to lasting peace.[1] The parties reject unilateral actions altering Jerusalem’s character and status and call for an internationally guaranteed special statute.[1] These provisions express the parties’ diplomatic position on Jerusalem alongside the agreement’s more directly operational provisions for religious freedom and Church activity.[1]

The Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs interprets the Holy See’s approach as favoring guarantees for the inviolability and maintenance of holy places, freedom of access, and freedom of worship in accordance with the 1852 status quo.[22] Its account also emphasizes the agreement’s commitment to equal membership in Palestinian society regardless of religious affiliation.[22]

Concern for Christian communities has included those in the West Bank — known by its original, indigenous Jewish name of Judea and Samaria.[7] A background assessment published in 2000 described a declining Christian population there, in contrast to a rising Christian population in Israel.[7] Access to holy places, their maintenance, and the protection of their surroundings formed related concerns at that time.[7]

The 2015 Comprehensive Agreement concerns the Church’s operation in areas of the Holy Land under Palestinian control and includes provisions protecting Christians’ rights.[19] It also reaffirms support for a negotiated and peaceful resolution of the conflict.[19] Its combination of Church-related provisions and diplomatic language continued the relationship’s dual attention to religious institutions and the political setting in which they operate.[5][19]

The Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs quotes the 2015 agreement as supporting a just, comprehensive, and peaceful settlement consistent with international law and relevant UN resolutions.[2] It also quotes support for an independent, sovereign, democratic, and viable Palestinian state based on the pre-1967 borders, including East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, living in peace and security with its neighbors.[2]

Diplomatic cooperation has not meant participation in every Palestinian initiative.[23] In 2015, the Holy See said it was not a participant in a Palestinian proposal to raise its flag at UN headquarters and asked that references to the Holy See be removed.[23] Its statement that it had “no intention of being a partner” in that initiative concerned the flag proposal, separately from the bilateral agreement.[23]

05Significance

The transition from official relations with the PLO to an agreement with the State of Palestine made Palestinian statehood an explicit feature of the bilateral relationship.[5][1] The agreement nevertheless retained a substantial practical purpose: regulating essential aspects of Catholic Church life and activity in Palestinian-controlled territory.[5][19] Its significance therefore extends across both international recognition and the circumstances of a religious community.[5][19]

Papal encounters have supplied another channel of engagement alongside legal agreements.[3][13] Benedict XVI’s 2009 statement joined support for a Palestinian homeland to security, peace with neighboring states, and rejection of violence and terrorism.[13] Francis’s 2014 prayer gathering brought the Israeli and Palestinian presidents together without presenting the occasion as a substitute for negotiations.[3] These initiatives linked support for Palestinian aspirations with efforts to restore a political process involving Israel.[3][13]

For Palestinian representatives, the embassy opening represented a further advance in recognition and bilateral relations.[20] Ambassador Issa Kassissieh described the planned embassy as a “big achievement” and said that the pope and apostolic nuncio had adopted a position recognizing the State of Palestine on the 1967 borders.[20] The embassy followed the upgraded relationship embodied in the 2015 agreement.[20]

In October 2025, Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin associated formal recognition with the Comprehensive Agreement concluded ten years earlier.[24] He reiterated support for a just and comprehensive peace grounded in international law and relevant UN resolutions, and for a Palestinian state encompassing the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza.[24] His description of the two-state solution as the right path, followed by Leo XIV’s discussion of that approach with Abbas the next month, demonstrated its continuing place in Holy See diplomacy.[24][21]

06Controversies

Israel objected to the 2015 agreement as premature and harmful to efforts to resume direct negotiations.[25] Its Foreign Ministry also criticized what it called a one-sided text that ignored Jewish historical rights and Israeli interests in Jerusalem.[2] An August 2015 American Jewish Committee article criticized the expansion of relations in the context of Palestinian pursuit of statehood outside direct negotiations and reported objections from Israel and Jewish leaders that it represented a setback to peace.[26]

The recognition decision also formed part of a wider disagreement over whether Palestinian statehood should precede or follow a final-status settlement.[18] Iceland, Sweden, and the Vatican were identified in a 2015 analysis as governments that had directly recognized Palestine rather than maintaining an approach centered on a negotiated final-status agreement.[18] That analysis argued that these governments had acted on statehood without correspondingly aligning their policies on borders, Jerusalem, and refugees.[18] The United States and Israel opposed Palestinian efforts to obtain recognition outside negotiations with Israel.[17]

Accounts attach recognition to different milestones: the Holy See’s response to the 2012 UN vote, February 2013, and the 2015 agreement.[5][27] A 2014 report described support for the UN vote as de facto recognition, while later accounts and Parolin’s 2025 remarks associated formal recognition with the Comprehensive Agreement.[16][24] These descriptions distinguish, with varying terminology, changes in diplomatic usage from the conclusion of a formal bilateral treaty.[5][24]

More recent disagreements have concerned the war in Gaza.[24] In his October 2025 interview, Parolin called the October 7 attack unjustifiable, said the Holy See had condemned it immediately, and called for the hostages’ release.[24] In the same interview, he supported Palestinian statehood while criticizing the effects of Israel’s campaign in Gaza on civilians.[24]

Sources

  1. 1Jewish Virtual Library, Vatican-Israel Relations: The PLO-Vatican Agreement, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  2. 2Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, The Holy See and Israel: The Historic Fight against the Jews and their State, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  3. 3World Jewish Congress, June 8 set for Peres, Abbas prayer for peace with Pope at Vatican, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  4. 4Encyclopedia.com, Vatican and the Middle East, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  5. 5The Times of Israel, Vatican Signs Palestine Treaty, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  6. 6U.S. Department of State, Holy See (03/10/10), accessed on November 7, 2026.
  7. 7The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, The Vatican and the Middle East, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  8. 8Jewish Virtual Library, Vatican, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  9. 9Jerusalem Institute for Policy Research, Freedom of Religion in Jerusalem, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  10. 10Office of the Historian, Historical Documents, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  11. 11The Jerusalem Post, Diplomacy: The pope and the Palestinians, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  12. 12Jewish Virtual Library, Vatican City Virtual Jewish History Tour, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  13. 13World Jewish Congress, Welcoming Pope Benedict, Mahmud Abbas attacks Israel's "apartheid wall", accessed on November 7, 2026.
  14. 14EveryCRSReport, Congressional Research Service, Israel: Background and U.S. Relations, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  15. 15Globes, Pope Francis in Israel: “End the Conflict”, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  16. 16Ynet, Just Don’t Upset Anyone: A Pope on a Tightrope, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  17. 17Congress.gov, Congressional Research Service, Pope Francis and Selected Global Issues, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  18. 18The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, Palestinian Recognition Analysis, 2015, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  19. 19The Times of Israel, Vatican–Palestine Accord Takes Effect, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  20. 20The Times of Israel, Palestinian Embassy at the Vatican, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  21. 21The Times of Israel, Pope Leo Meets Abbas, 2025, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  22. 22Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, Pope John Paul II and the Jews: An Evaluation, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  23. 23Maariv, 119 Countries Voted in Favor: The Palestinian Authority Flag Will Be Raised at UN Headquarters, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  24. 24Mako, Vatican Criticism of Israel, and the Strong Condemnation of the October 7 Massacre, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  25. 25Maariv, Foreign Ministry: “The Vatican’s Hasty Move Harms the Chances of Reaching a Peace Agreement”, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  26. 26American Jewish Committee, How Pope Francis is Building on 50 Years of Jewish-Catholic Entente, accessed on November 7, 2026.
  27. 27Ynet, Pope Takes a Sharper Tone Against Israel: “Children Were Sprayed with Machine Guns”, accessed on November 7, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What are Holy See–Palestine relations?

    Holy See–Palestine relations are the bilateral relationship between the Holy See and Palestinian representatives. They cover diplomatic recognition, agreements concerning the Catholic Church, and efforts toward Israeli-Palestinian peace. The relationship developed from official contacts with the Palestine Liberation Organization into a Comprehensive Agreement with the State of Palestine, signed in June 2015.

  • What does the 2015 Comprehensive Agreement cover?

    The 2015 Comprehensive Agreement governs essential aspects of the Catholic Church’s life and activity in Palestinian-controlled areas and reflects the upgraded bilateral relationship between the Holy See and the State of Palestine. It also reaffirms support for a negotiated and peaceful resolution of the conflict. The agreement entered into force after the parties notified each other that their procedural requirements had been fulfilled.

  • How did formal relations between the Holy See and Palestinian representatives begin?

    Official relations between the Holy See and the Palestine Liberation Organization began in October 1994, with the PLO identified as the representative of the Palestinian people. A joint commission established in January 1998 began negotiating an agreement concerning the Catholic Church and Christian communities in the Holy Land. The parties signed the Basic Agreement in February 2000.

  • What does the 2000 Basic Agreement say about religious freedom and the Catholic Church?

    The 2000 Basic Agreement commits the PLO to freedom of religion and conscience and to protecting citizens’ human and civil rights without discrimination based on religion or belief. It recognizes the Church’s freedom to carry out spiritual, religious, charitable, educational, and cultural activities, as well as its rights in economic, legal, and fiscal matters. It also calls for maintaining the Status Quo in Christian holy places wherever that arrangement applies.

  • What was the purpose of Pope Francis’s 2014 prayer meeting with the Israeli and Palestinian presidents?

    Pope Francis’s June 2014 prayer meeting at the Vatican was intended to create an atmosphere favorable to renewed Israeli-Palestinian talks, not to mediate between the parties. Francis invited Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Israeli President Shimon Peres after American-led peace talks had foundered in April. The gathering was part of his efforts to restart the peace process.

  • Why did Israel object to the 2015 agreement with the State of Palestine?

    Israel objected that the 2015 agreement was premature and could harm efforts to resume direct negotiations. Israel’s Foreign Ministry also criticized what it described as a one-sided text that ignored Jewish historical rights and Israeli interests in Jerusalem. The objections reflected a wider disagreement over whether Palestinian statehood should be addressed through direct negotiations or recognized beforehand.

  • What was the significance of the Palestinian embassy opening at the Vatican?

    The Palestinian embassy’s official opening at the Vatican in January 2017 marked a further advance in bilateral relations and recognition, following the 2015 Comprehensive Agreement. Mahmoud Abbas attended the inauguration. Palestinian ambassador Issa Kassissieh described the planned embassy as a “big achievement.”