← All articles

Total current articles · 4,831

If Israel Lost the War

Published

01In brief

If Israel Lost the War is a counterfactual work by Richard Z. Chesnoff, Edward Klein, and Robert Littell imagining an Israeli defeat in the 1967 Six-Day War. Its premise turns on the possibility that Arab forces might have struck first; Golda Meir expressed the fear underlying that scenario in the words, “Imagine if Nasser had reached our airfields first… That was a nightmare that would not let us rest.” The book depicts the destruction of the Jewish state within six days and provoked a hostile response from some Israeli commentators when it appeared in Hebrew.

02Overview

The work explores a reversal of the Six-Day War’s outcome through an imagined sequence beginning with an Arab first strike and ending with Israel ceasing to exist.[1] Its Hebrew title is אילו נוצחה ישראל, transliterated as Ilu Nutz'ha Yisrael and translated as If Israel Were Defeated.[1]

The book belongs to the counterfactual-history tradition, in which a change to a key historical event becomes the starting point for imagining a different outcome.[3] Its authors described their approach as combining real facts with what they regarded as plausible imagination, and anticipated that Israeli readers might be particularly shocked by their conclusions.[1]

03Origins and History

Chesnoff, Klein, and Littell wrote the work shortly after the Six-Day War; they were three American journalists familiar with and supportive of Israel.[2] The book’s premise drew on the fear surrounding the prewar crisis in May 1967, when Israel had a Jewish population of approximately 2.5 million.[2] High-school students dug trenches in neighborhoods whose men had left for the front, while radio commentator Haim Herzog said that, for his own safety, he would prefer not to be an Egyptian pilot over Tel Aviv.[2]

The possibility of an initial attack on Israel’s airfields figured prominently in recollections associated with the book.[1] Golda Meir privately asked Chesnoff to imagine Nasser reaching those airfields first and described the prospect as a nightmare.[1] Yitzhak Rabin told Klein and Littell that a successful initial Arab air strike could have decided the outcome, adding that he would have hated for Israel’s existence to depend on the United States.[1]

Bibliographic records identify both 1967 and 1969 publication dates: a catalog entry gives 1967 and names Coward-McCann of New York as publisher, while a biographical bibliography lists the work among Littell’s 1969 publications with R. Z. Chesnoff and E. Klein.[4][5] An authority-file citation also records “Chesnoff, R. Z. If Israel lost the war, 1969.”[6]

In Israel, Maariv, then the country’s most widely circulated newspaper, published chapters before issuing the work in full Hebrew translation.[2]

04Counterfactual Scenario

The imagined war begins with Israel losing its composure in the opening moments of the conflict.[1] A White House situation room struggles to explain how events have unfolded, while Israeli leaders shelter in the Knesset as Jordanian mortar shells shatter its windows and smoke rises from nearby Rehavia.[1] The alternative sequence concludes with Israel ceasing to exist six days later.[1]

An Israel Hayom commentary describes the novel as portraying mass torture and massacre of Israelis, the execution of captured soldiers, abuse of Israeli women, assassinations of Israeli leaders, and institutions intended to replace those of the Jewish state.[7] These episodes belong to the book’s imagined Arab victory, rather than to a narrative of the war that actually occurred.[7]

05Significance and Reception

The Hebrew publication elicited opposition: Mark Geffen, editor-in-chief of the Mapam newspaper Al HaMishmar, called for a boycott, and Uri Avnery attacked the book in HaOlam HaZeh and the American magazine Life.[2] Its placement among examples of Jewish counterfactual thought-experimentation also situates it within a literary practice of exploring alternative historical outcomes.[3]

The broader question of an Israeli defeat in 1967 has also been used to examine the stakes of the prewar crisis.[8] One counterfactual assessment holds that defeat would likely have imperiled Israel’s existence and produced very grave diplomatic consequences.[8] That assessment connects the danger to warnings by Israeli generals that Prime Minister Levi Eshkol’s hesitation placed Israel’s existence at stake, Arab leaders’ public declarations against Israel, and Egypt’s military understandings with neighboring Arab states.[8]

The same discussion emphasizes that Arab hostility preceded the war and therefore cannot be explained solely by its outcome.[8] It also distinguishes Israel’s inability to impose peace from its Arab antagonists’ inability to impose military victory, and associates Israeli control of the West Bank — known by its original, indigenous Jewish name of Judea and Samaria — with increased terrorism and human hardship, including the hardships of occupation.[8]

06Controversies

The central interpretive issue is the plausibility of the imagined defeat and its consequences: the authors presented their account as plausible imagination grounded in facts, not as events that occurred.[1] A 2017 Globes columnist wrote that the book’s logic and some of its assumptions were open to dispute.[2] Statements about what defeat would have meant for Israel’s survival remain counterfactual judgments rather than verifiable historical outcomes.[8]

Reference sources classify the work differently: Internet Archive catalogs it as a novel, while the Robert Littell entry labels it non-fiction.[4][5] Encyclopedia.com includes it among alternate-history examples in a section on counterfactual thought-experimentation.[3]

A related account of prewar fear includes a claim that the government dug 14,000 mass graves in Tel Aviv’s Yarkon Park; the presentation containing that figure does not independently corroborate it.[8]

Sources

  1. 1Globes, June 1967: It Could Have Ended Differently, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  2. 2Globes, What If Israel Had Been Defeated? Yoav Karny, Washington, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  3. 3Encyclopedia.com, Science Fiction and Fantasy, Jewish, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  4. 4Internet Archive, If Israel lost the war : Chesnoff, Richard Z., 1937- : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  5. 5Encyclopedia.com, Littell, Robert, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  6. 6Library of Congress, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  7. 7Israel Hayom, World silent as Hamas continues to threaten Israel – www.israelhayom.com, accessed on November 3, 2026.
  8. 8The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, Consequences of the 1967 War, accessed on November 3, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What is If Israel Lost the War?

    If Israel Lost the War is a counterfactual work by Richard Z. Chesnoff, Edward Klein, and Robert Littell that imagines Israel losing the 1967 Six-Day War. Its scenario begins with an Arab first strike and ends with Israel ceasing to exist six days later.

  • What happens in the imagined scenario in If Israel Lost the War?

    In If Israel Lost the War, Israeli leaders shelter in the Knesset as Jordanian mortar shells shatter its windows, while a White House situation room struggles to explain how events unfolded. An Israel Hayom commentary describes the imagined Arab victory as involving mass torture and massacre of Israelis, executions of captured soldiers, abuse of Israeli women, and assassinations of Israeli leaders. These events are part of the counterfactual scenario, not the actual history of the war.

  • Why did the authors imagine Israel losing the Six-Day War?

    The authors built the scenario around the fear that Arab forces might strike Israel’s airfields first during the prewar crisis in May 1967. Golda Meir described that possibility to Chesnoff as a nightmare, and Yitzhak Rabin told Klein and Littell that a successful initial Arab air strike could have decided the outcome. The authors said they combined real facts with what they regarded as plausible imagination.

  • When was If Israel Lost the War published?

    Bibliographic records give both 1967 and 1969 as publication dates for If Israel Lost the War. A catalog entry lists Coward-McCann of New York as publisher in 1967, while a biographical bibliography and an authority-file citation list the work in 1969.

  • How was If Israel Lost the War received in Israel?

    The Hebrew publication of If Israel Lost the War drew opposition from Israeli commentators. Mark Geffen, editor-in-chief of the Mapam newspaper Al HaMishmar, called for a boycott, and Uri Avnery criticized the book in HaOlam HaZeh and the American magazine Life. Maariv had published chapters before the full Hebrew translation appeared.

  • What does If Israel Lost the War say about the consequences of an Israeli defeat?

    If Israel Lost the War depicts Israel ceasing to exist after an imagined Arab victory, but the consequences described are counterfactual rather than historical events. A separate counterfactual assessment holds that defeat would likely have imperiled Israel’s existence and produced very grave diplomatic consequences; the book’s logic and some of its assumptions have also been described as open to dispute.