← All articles

Total current articles · 5,220

The Fateful Triangle

Published

01In brief

The Fateful Triangle: The United States, Israel, and the Palestinians is a book by Noam Chomsky examining U.S.-Israeli relations and their connections with Palestinians. First published in 1983, it was updated in 1999 and ranges across Palestinian national rights, the administration of occupied territories, and the 1982 Lebanon war and its aftermath. Chomsky presents it as a focused intervention on aspects of these relationships he believed had been insufficiently addressed or misrepresented, rather than as a comprehensive history.

02Overview

Chomsky says in the preface that the book is not meant to be a comprehensive analysis or a general history. He describes its purpose as drawing attention to aspects of the U.S.-Israel relationship and the parties’ relations with Palestinians that, in his view, had been neglected or misrepresented.[2] He also says that his criticism of Israeli policy is intended partly to focus attention on U.S. government policy and on what he calls “our responsibility in shaping or tolerating these policies.”[2]

The updated edition carries the discussion from the 1983 account to the time of its revision. Chomsky frames recurring regional crises as connected to unresolved problems, including the Israel-Arab conflict and U.S. strategic interests in the region; these are his interpretations and organizing framework.[2]

The book’s stated framework gives national self-determination a central place. Chomsky defines “rejectionism” to include denying Palestinian Arabs’ right to national self-determination, as well as denying Jewish national self-determination. He contrasts this with “accommodation” and states that Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs have equal human rights and valid claims to national self-determination in the territory of the former Palestine.[2]

03Origins and Publication

The book was first published by South End Press in Boston in 1983. The first-edition catalog record notes that it includes bibliographical references and an index.[3] An updated edition followed in 1999; its foreword is dated January of that year and signed by Edward W. Said.[2]

The updated edition was first published in the United Kingdom by Pluto Press and identifies 1983 as the original edition’s copyright year.[2] A later reference by Richard Landes cites a 1999 South End Press edition in New York.[4] A 2011 Sh’ma bibliography gives Cambridge and lists South End Press with the years 1983 and 1999 without assigning each year to a particular edition.[5] These records support the two principal publication years while leaving the relationship among the 1999 publication records unclear.

The title can also refer to a separate 2003 edited volume, Israel, the Hashemites, and the Palestinians: The Fateful Triangle, edited by Efraim Karsh and P. R. Kumaraswamy and published by Frank Cass.[6] That book is distinct from Chomsky’s work.

04Writing and Publication Context

In a later interview, Chomsky recalled that after the 1982 Beirut bombing he wrote an article anticipating further conflict and submitted it to The Nation, but received no response. He said that frustration at being unable to get his account of Sabra and Shatila into the left press prompted him to write The Fateful Triangle.[7] He also recalled writing the book mostly at night because he had no other free time.[7]

This recollection presents the book, in Chomsky’s account, as partly a response to the difficulty he encountered in placing his views on the Lebanon conflict in a publication he considered part of the left press.[7]

05Analytical Practice and Organization

The updated edition organizes its analysis around U.S.-Israeli relations, Palestinian national rights, the history and administration of occupied territories, and the 1982 Lebanon war and its aftermath.[2] Its chapter titles signal the range of the inquiry, including “The Origins of the ‘Special Relationship,’” “Rejectionism and Accommodation,” and “Israel and Palestine: Historical Backgrounds.”[2]

Other chapter titles refer to the 1982 Israeli operation in Lebanon as “Peace for Galilee,” the Palestinian uprising, and Washington’s “Peace Process.” The contents also include chapters on the Oslo agreements.[2] Together, these topics show how the book connects historical background and policy debates with events and diplomatic initiatives addressed in the updated edition.

06Significance

Edward W. Said’s foreword to the 1999 edition presents the book as a major intervention on the conflict and praises the breadth of Chomsky’s Israeli and U.S. sourcing. Said also emphasizes that the new edition added treatment of the Oslo and Wye accords; these are Said’s evaluative judgments rather than evidence of a critical consensus.[2]

The book also continued to serve as a reference point in later political commentary. Harriet Mandel cited it in discussing Chomsky’s response to the 1975 United Nations resolution on Zionism,[5] while Richard Landes invoked it critically in a broader argument about post-9/11 conspiracy thinking.[4]

07Controversies

The book’s political interpretations and terminology have been discussed critically. In an article about the 1975 United Nations General Assembly resolution declaring Zionism a form of racism, Harriet Mandel attributes to Chomsky the criticism that the resolution targeted Zionism itself rather than Israeli government policies. She also reports his objection to what he called the “profound hypocrisy” of states backing the resolution.[5] Mandel’s account concerns Chomsky’s response to that resolution and is not a comprehensive assessment of the book.[5]

Richard Landes offers a sharply critical characterization, presenting the book as an example of a perspective that treats the Republican administration as a “near enemy” and, in his view, thereby denies the existence of a “far enemy.”[4] This is Landes’s polemical interpretation, not a neutral summary of the book’s argument. The available discussions are limited and reflect differing interpretations; the book’s stated positions are best distinguished from later commentary about them.

Sources

  1. 1Encyclopedia.com, Chomsky, (Avram) Noam 1928-, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  2. 2Internet Archive, Chomsky, The Fateful Triangle, updated edition, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  3. 3Internet Archive, The fateful triangle : the United States, Israel, and the Palestinians : Chomsky, Noam : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  4. 4Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, The Jews as Contested Ground in Postmodern Conspiracy Theory, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  5. 5Berman Jewish Policy Archive, Sh’ma, “Working with the United Nations, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  6. 6Encyclopedia.com, Karsh, Efraim 1953-, accessed on October 27, 2026.
  7. 7Internet Archive, Chomsky, How the World Works, accessed on October 27, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What is The Fateful Triangle?

    The Fateful Triangle: The United States, Israel, and the Palestinians is a book by Noam Chomsky examining U.S.-Israeli relations and their connections with Palestinians. First published in 1983 and updated in 1999, it discusses Palestinian national rights, the administration of occupied territories, and the 1982 Lebanon war and its aftermath. Chomsky presented it as a focused intervention, not a comprehensive history.

  • When was The Fateful Triangle published, and who published it?

    South End Press first published Noam Chomsky’s The Fateful Triangle in Boston in 1983. An updated edition followed in 1999, first published in the United Kingdom by Pluto Press. The relationship among the different records for the 1999 publication is unclear.

  • What prompted Noam Chomsky to write The Fateful Triangle?

    Noam Chomsky later recalled that he wrote The Fateful Triangle partly because he could not get his account of the Lebanon conflict into a publication he considered part of the left press. After the 1982 Beirut bombing, he said, he submitted an article anticipating further conflict to The Nation but received no response. He also recalled writing the book mostly at night because he had no other free time.

  • What topics does The Fateful Triangle cover?

    The updated edition of The Fateful Triangle examines U.S.-Israeli relations, Palestinian national rights, the history and administration of occupied territories, and the 1982 Lebanon war and its aftermath. Its chapters also address the Palestinian uprising, Washington’s “Peace Process,” and the Oslo agreements, alongside historical background and policy debates.

  • What does The Fateful Triangle say about national self-determination?

    The Fateful Triangle gives national self-determination a central place in its framework. Chomsky defines “rejectionism” to include denying Palestinian Arabs’ right to national self-determination, as well as denying Jewish national self-determination. He states that Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs have equal human rights and valid claims to national self-determination in the territory of the former Palestine.

  • How was The Fateful Triangle received or discussed?

    Edward W. Said’s foreword to the 1999 edition presents The Fateful Triangle as a major intervention on the conflict and praises the breadth of its Israeli and U.S. sourcing. Said also notes that the updated edition added discussion of the Oslo and Wye accords; these are his evaluations, not evidence of a critical consensus. Later commentators cited the book in political discussions, including Harriet Mandel and Richard Landes, who offered sharply differing interpretations.