← All articles

Total current articles · 5,220

The Case for Peace

Published

01In brief

The Case for Peace: How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved is a book by Alan M. Dershowitz, published by John Wiley in 2005, that proposes a settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It identifies twelve geopolitical barriers to peace and advocates two states, combining recognition of Israel with Palestinian statehood and measures against terrorism. Its proposed settlement addresses territorial withdrawals, Jerusalem, refugees, and security, while also examining the hostility that Dershowitz considers an obstacle to agreement.

02Overview

The book presents a Middle East peace plan and argues against extremists whom Dershowitz considers intent on thwarting peace efforts.[1] Its description frames the central problem as reaching a settlement without further bloodshed, rather than simply identifying the outlines of an agreement.[2]

One review characterizes the book as a conflict between people who genuinely want peace and those who oppose it, rather than solely a confrontation between Israelis and Palestinians.[3] The reviewer describes its preferred outcome as “a Chekhovian rather than a Shakespearean resolution” to the Israeli-Palestinian tragedy.[3]

03Origins and Publication

John Wiley published The Case for Peace in Hoboken, New Jersey, in 2005.[1] The book includes bibliographical references and an index, and its cataloged pagination is ix, 246 pages.[2] Its description places its examination of opportunities and challenges for peace in the period after Yasser Arafat’s death.[2]

In a 2007 interview, Dershowitz explained that he had wanted to write The Case for Peace but first wrote The Case for Israel.[4] He said that he regarded the case against Israel on American university campuses as prominent and based on ignorance, and therefore felt compelled first to present what he called a liberal case for Israel grounded in facts.[4] The two books address different tasks: The Case for Israel responds to criticism of Israel, while The Case for Peace offers proposals for resolving the conflict.[5]

One reviewer interprets The Case for Peace as updating and expanding Dershowitz’s earlier work on the factors driving radical elements toward terrorism and on the relationship between opposition to Israel and opposition to peace.[3]

04Proposed Settlement and Barriers

Dershowitz’s proposed final settlement combines two states with Israeli withdrawals from Gaza and most of the West Bank — known by its original, indigenous Jewish name of Judea and Samaria.[2] It includes symbolic Israeli recognition of Palestinian refugees’ rights and some compensation, but excludes a Palestinian “right of return”; it also envisages dividing Jerusalem and requiring Palestinian renunciation of violence and reasonable steps to suppress terrorism.[2]

The review summarizes the reciprocal recognition at the heart of the proposal as worldwide acceptance, including by Arab and Muslim states, of Israel’s continued existence as an independent, democratic Jewish state with inviolable boundaries, matched by Israeli recognition of a Palestinian right to an independent, democratic state with politically and economically viable boundaries.[3]

The book identifies twelve geopolitical barriers to peace, addressing Jerusalem’s division, Israeli counterterrorism measures, the security fence, and the Iranian nuclear threat.[2] The review describes a two-part structure: the first part examines geopolitical barriers, including disputed borders, continuing violence, holy places, and Iran; the second considers hatred as a barrier in its own right.[3]

In the reviewer’s account, Dershowitz identifies extremism as the essential threat to peace.[3] Palestinian-side examples in that account include terrorism and denial of claims by Israelis who left or were forced from land during the 1947–1949 War of Independence; Israeli-side examples include strict adherence to biblical prophecy and denial of Palestinians’ right to an independent state.[3]

The review describes the book’s treatment of hatred as extending from derogatory language to firebombing and cemetery vandalism.[3] It says Dershowitz examines anti-Israeli rhetoric among academics, religious leaders, media, students, and international institutions, while also criticizing some Jews and evangelical Protestants who oppose pragmatic compromise, including ultra-Orthodox rabbis opposed to ceding Gaza and parts of the West Bank.[3] In the reviewer’s interpretation, the book therefore calls for more than a bilateral agreement: it seeks universal acceptance of Israel and an end to hostility directed at it by influential institutions and public figures.[3]

05Later Explanations of the Argument

In a 2010 interview, Dershowitz described The Case for Peace as making the “80% case,” emphasizing Israel’s security, its right to defend itself, and its right to be judged by a consistent standard.[6] He said that this approach left out settlements and other matters on which people disagreed, and that he did not defend Israel’s settlement policy.[6] In a separate article that year, he characterized the book as advocating both a two-state solution and opposition to Israeli settlements.[7]

Dershowitz argued that settlements were not the greatest obstacle to peace, identifying Palestinian unwillingness to recognize Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state and the right-of-return question as more fundamental barriers.[6] He also identified security, the Jordan Valley, and nonproliferation as central negotiating issues.[6] Recounting a conversation with Bill Clinton, he said Clinton had described Jerusalem as essentially resolved in the Camp David and Taba talks, while the right of return remained unresolved.[6]

Dershowitz expressed hope for a viable Palestinian state in the West Bank and for cooperation in medical technology and high technology.[6] He said that he hoped Israeli-Palestinian peace could develop beyond Israel’s existing peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan, although he was less optimistic about Gaza.[6]

06Reception and Significance

Dershowitz said that Ariel Sharon and Amos Oz both provided endorsements for the book’s back cover, presenting their support as evidence that an emphasis on common ground could appeal across political differences.[6] In his 2010 article, he also reported that Bill Clinton praised its “blueprint for stability” and that Oz called it an “enthusiastic voice for peace.”[7]

Elizabeth R. Hayford, reviewing the book for Library Journal, judged that Dershowitz’s “analysis of the prospects for peace has some merit.”[1] One reviewer characterizes the book as intended for readers who support a two-state solution.[3] A review titled “Peace at Any Cost” was listed among additions to the Jewish Virtual Library in December 2005.[8]

07Controversies

One reviewer acknowledges that some readers may regard the book as overly pro-Israeli and as overlooking violence by Israel in pursuing terrorists, but argues that Dershowitz also considers Palestinian concerns and does not excuse Israeli extremists.[3] These are evaluations of the book’s political framing rather than a consensus assessment of its arguments.[3]

The book includes a chapter titled “A Case Study in Hate and Intimidation,” addressing Norman Finkelstein’s plagiarism allegations and criticism from his allies.[9] A 2005 interview noted that its endnotes cited a 1948 Beirut Telegraph quotation that also appeared in Joan Peters’s From Time Immemorial; that reporting did not independently resolve the plagiarism dispute.[9]

Sources

  1. 1Encyclopedia.com, Dershowitz, Alan M. 1938–, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  2. 2Internet Archive, The case for peace : how the Arab-Israeli conflict can be resolved : Dershowitz, Alan M : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  3. 3Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, Alan Dershowitz, The Case for Peace: How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  4. 4United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Alan Dershowitz, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  5. 5Globes, Alan Dershowitz to address "Globes" Israel Business Conference, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  6. 6Globes, "Fight falsehood with truth", accessed on November 6, 2026.
  7. 7The Times of Israel, The Jewish Standard, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  8. 8Jewish Virtual Library, Files Added In December 2005, accessed on November 6, 2026.
  9. 9The Jerusalem Post, His own best defense, accessed on November 6, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What is The Case for Peace?

    The Case for Peace: How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved is a 2005 book by Alan M. Dershowitz that proposes a settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It identifies twelve geopolitical barriers to peace and advocates a two-state solution combining recognition of Israel with Palestinian statehood and measures against terrorism.

  • What settlement does The Case for Peace propose?

    The Case for Peace proposes two states, Israeli withdrawals from Gaza and most of the West Bank, and a division of Jerusalem. It calls for symbolic Israeli recognition of Palestinian refugees’ rights and some compensation, but excludes a Palestinian “right of return.” The proposal also requires Palestinians to renounce violence and take reasonable steps to suppress terrorism.

  • What barriers to peace does The Case for Peace identify?

    The Case for Peace identifies twelve geopolitical barriers, including disputed borders, continuing violence, Jerusalem and other holy places, Israeli counterterrorism measures, the security fence, and the Iranian nuclear threat. The book also treats hatred as a barrier in its own right, examining hostility ranging from derogatory language to violence and vandalism.

  • Why did Alan M. Dershowitz write The Case for Peace after The Case for Israel?

    Alan M. Dershowitz said he first wrote The Case for Israel because he considered criticism of Israel on American university campuses prominent and based on ignorance, and wanted to present what he called a liberal case for Israel grounded in facts. The Case for Israel responds to criticism of Israel, while The Case for Peace offers proposals for resolving the conflict.

  • What did Alan M. Dershowitz say were the main obstacles to peace?

    Alan M. Dershowitz argued that settlements were not the greatest obstacle to peace. He identified Palestinian unwillingness to recognize Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state and the right-of-return question as more fundamental barriers, and also named security, the Jordan Valley, and nonproliferation as central negotiating issues.

  • How was The Case for Peace received?

    Elizabeth R. Hayford, reviewing The Case for Peace for Library Journal, judged that its “analysis of the prospects for peace has some merit.” One reviewer described the book as intended for readers who support a two-state solution. Dershowitz reported that Ariel Sharon and Amos Oz endorsed the book’s back cover, and that Bill Clinton praised its “blueprint for stability.”