01In brief
In 2024, South Africa and Turkey demonstrated their diplomatic alignment when Turkey intervened in South Africa's case against Israel at the International Court of Justice — a proceeding centered on contested allegations under the Genocide Convention that Israel rejected as baseless.
02Joint Action at the International Court of Justice
The most consequential episode in recent South Africa–Turkey relations has been Turkey's alignment with South Africa's case against Israel at the International Court of Justice. On January 11, 2024, South Africa filed an application accusing Israel of violating the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in connection with its military operations in Gaza — allegations that Israel rejected as baseless.[15] South Africa's application cited statements by leaders of several countries, including Turkey, characterizing Israel's actions in terms that the application treated as relevant context; a YIVO-published analysis challenged this use of political statements as evidentiary material.[11]
On January 12, 2024, President Erdoğan publicly stated that Turkey was providing documents to support South Africa's case, describing the material as consisting mostly of visuals concerning Israeli strikes in Gaza and expressing his personal belief that Israel would be convicted.[13] Turkey's foreign ministry had reportedly been transmitting supporting documents to South Africa's legal team since January 2024.[2]
On May 1, 2024, Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan announced that Turkey had decided to formally intervene in the case and would submit a declaration once its legal work was complete.[2][18] Fidan also said Turkey was working with allies to encourage other countries to apply to join the proceedings.[16] As the ICJ simultaneously considered a new South African request for measures related to Israel's military operation in Rafah, Turkey signaled its support for that request as well.[19]
On August 7, 2024, Turkey's ambassador to the Netherlands, accompanied by Turkish legislators, submitted a formal declaration of intervention at The Hague.[15] Foreign Minister Fidan confirmed the filing, and Turkey was reported to be the fifth country to submit such an application.[3] The Washington Institute noted that Ankara's submission reportedly avoided committing to accept the court's eventual judgment as binding.[4] At the time of filing, the ICJ had not yet ruled on whether to accept Turkey or other applicants as intervening parties; if accepted, participating countries would be permitted to make written submissions and address public hearings.[15] The ICJ's findings, in any case, do not carry criminal enforcement power.[12]
Israel rejected South Africa's genocide allegations throughout the proceedings as unfounded.[13][15] The underlying allegations remain legally contested and have not been adjudicated on the merits by the Court.
03Significance
Analysts have situated South Africa–Turkey cooperation within the broader dynamics of the Global South and international criticism of Israel.[5] Turkey's ICJ intervention alongside South Africa was seen as emblematic of a wider diplomatic alignment, with one analysis describing both governments as anchoring a coordinated campaign at The Hague concerning Israel's conduct.[6] South Africa, for its part, represented both an economically significant bilateral partner and a vehicle through which Turkey could reinforce its standing among African and developing-world states.
From an Israeli and pro-Israel analytical standpoint, the Turkey–South Africa axis at the ICJ exemplifies the use of international legal institutions to apply diplomatic pressure on Israel, with the genocide allegations serving a political function that critics argue goes well beyond the evidentiary standards the Genocide Convention was designed to require.[11] The proceedings have not produced a finding that genocide occurred, and Israel continues to contest both the factual claims and the legal framework advanced by South Africa and its intervening partners.
Sources
- 1Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Turkey's Return to Africa.
- 2Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Turkey Poised to Join South Africa's Genocide Lawsuit Against Israel at ICJ.
- 3Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Turkey Officially Requests to Join South African Genocide Case at ICJ.
- 4The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, Israel-Turkey Relations Nearing a Rupture.
- 5Institute for National Security Studies, Symposium: Iran's Involvement in the African Continent.
- 6Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Erdogan's Rivalry with Israel Has a New Front: Africa.
- 7U.S. Department of State.
- 8Congress.gov, Congressional Research Service, "Turkey (Türkiye): Major Issues and U.S. Relations.
- 9Jewish Virtual Library, Turkey-Israel Relations.
- 10Jewish Virtual Library, Israel Accused of 'Genocide' at the International Court of Justice.
- 11YIVO Institute for Jewish Research, South African Lawfare at The Hague.
- 12Encyclopaedia Britannica, Genocide: Recent developments.
- 13The Times of Israel.
- 14The Jerusalem Post, Reuters.
- 15The Times of Israel, August 2024.
- 16Mako, N12.
- 17Mosaic.
- 18Ynet.
- 19Globes.