← All articles

Total current articles · 5,202

October 2000 Protests in Israel

Published

01In brief

The October 2000 protests in Israel were a wave of demonstrations, riots, and intercommunal clashes that took place principally on October 1–10, 2000, amid the beginning of the Second Intifada. The subsequent Or Commission concluded that government handling of Arab citizens had been “primarily neglectful and discriminatory,” while also identifying failures in police preparedness and the conduct of some Arab leaders. The commission recorded 14 deaths: 12 Arab citizens of Israel, one Jewish citizen, and one resident of the Gaza Strip. The events involved widespread roadblocks, attacks on civilians and security forces, lethal police shootings, and Jewish attacks on Arabs, and severely damaged Jewish-Arab relations in Israel.

02Background

Ariel Sharon, then leader of the opposition, visited the Temple Mount on September 28, 2000, accompanied by Likud members and a large security force.[4][5] Palestinians perceived the visit as a provocation, and violent confrontations followed Friday-prayer demonstrations at the site.[4][5] The ensuing Second Intifada spread through the Palestinian territories, while Arab citizens of Israel demonstrated in solidarity with Palestinians and against Israeli government policies.[4][6] The Or Commission later treated the events of September 28–30 as background and possible immediate triggers, distinguishing them from the October 1–10 events that formed the principal subject of its inquiry.[1]

The unrest followed earlier disputes over home demolitions, land confiscation, discrimination against Arab municipalities, and public resources.[7] Demonstrations during 1998–2000 included confrontations near Sakhnin in March 2000, and the commission identified an escalation in which protests over ordinary civil issues developed into violent confrontations.[7] Its examination counted nine protest events in the two and a half years before October 2000 and “no less than fifty” during 2000 itself.[7] These local tensions coincided with the breakdown of the Oslo process and heightened conflict in East Jerusalem and the Palestinian territories.[7]

In its findings, the commission identified longstanding governmental neglect, discrimination, and unequal resource allocation as sources of distress among Arab citizens.[3] The problems included poverty and unemployment, shortages of land, deficiencies in education and infrastructure, and weaknesses in health and social services.[2][3] Unequal local-government budgets and low Arab employment in the civil service were also part of the background examined by the inquiry.[4] Alongside these conditions, the commission identified increased identification with the Palestinian struggle, the growth of Islamic politics, and political and ideological radicalization as contributing factors.[3]

Warnings about possible unrest preceded the immediate crisis.[4] The commission found that the Israel Security Agency had received warnings as early as May 2000 about potentially widespread disturbances but had not shared them with other Israeli security agencies.[4] A National Security Council document dated September 26 warned that activity “may include violent demonstrations, roadblocks, and attacks on symbols of the state, such as police stations, post offices, and bank branches.”[4] It also anticipated that Palestinian casualties could draw additional Arab citizens of Israel into demonstrations.[4]

Despite those indications, the commission found that police and political authorities had not adequately prepared for widespread unrest.[3] Planning, training, equipment, and operational policy were insufficient, and police were not properly positioned at locations already recognized as potential flashpoints.[3] The commission also identified insufficient communication between government representatives and Arab leaders as part of the circumstances surrounding the confrontations.[1]

03Course of Events

On October 1, Arab leaders called a general strike that received widespread support, and thousands of people demonstrated around Israel.[8] The Higher Arab Monitoring Committee called for demonstrations and processions amid heightened tensions following the Temple Mount confrontations.[3] Demonstrations and clashes spread through northern towns and villages, including Umm al-Fahm, Kafr Kana, Nazareth, Tur'an, Mashhad, Deir al-Asad, and Arraba, and extended to Fureidis, Jaffa, and the Negev.[9] Wadi Ara became a central flashpoint, with roadblocks, burning tires, stone-throwing, attacks on police stations, and confrontations with police.[10]

In Umm al-Fahm, protesters blocked the Wadi Ara road, and police used live ammunition and rubber-coated metal bullets.[8][9] Muhammad Ahmad Jabareen was killed, and Ahmad Jabareen was fatally wounded and died the following day.[9] The contemporary human-rights account recorded two people killed and hundreds injured in the October 1 demonstrations there.[8] In Nazareth and Jaffa, the first day also brought street clashes and property damage; 44 wounded people, most injured by rubber bullets, arrived at Nazareth hospitals.[9]

On October 2, roadblocks and stone-throwing continued around Umm al-Fahm and elsewhere, while police came under attack in Nazareth.[9] Confrontations also occurred in Acre, Jaffa, Kafr Qasim, and other locations, with protesters throwing stones and firebombs and police using live ammunition and rubber bullets in some incidents.[9] The chronology listed six people killed in incidents that day: Ala' Nassar and Aseel Asleh of Arraba; Imad Ghanayem and Walid Abu Saleh of Sakhnin; Iyad Loubna of Nazareth; and Salah Abu Jarad, a Gaza resident killed in Umm al-Fahm.[9]

Clashes continued on October 3 in Kafr Manda, Tamra, the Jezreel Valley, Nazareth, Tayibe, and Tira.[9] Ramiz Bushnaq was killed in Kafr Manda, while a funeral for Iyad Loubna drew more than 60,000 people and was followed by further clashes in Nazareth.[9] Approximately 100 fires were reported around the country that day, many attributed by police to nationalistic arson.[9] Sporadic arson during the unrest burned hundreds of acres of forest in central and northern Israel.[11] Prime Minister Ehud Barak met Arab community leaders on October 3 and announced a committee to examine the confrontations between police and Arabs.[9]

The scale of simultaneous disturbances made restoring order difficult and surprised the government.[4] Thousands participated in numerous locations, and major transportation routes remained blocked for prolonged periods.[3] Some towns and villages were effectively closed off for days, and road closures at one point cut the Galilee off from the rest of Israel.[11][12] An analysis published during the unrest on October 3 reported eight Arab citizens killed by police by that date and at least three instances of shooting at Israeli vehicles.[12]

The violence included attacks on security personnel and civilians with stones, Molotov cocktails, metal balls fired from slingshots, burning tires, and, in isolated cases, live ammunition.[3] Jewish travelers were attacked because they were Jewish, property was damaged, attempts were made to enter Jewish towns, and access to some communities was disrupted.[3] Public facilities and Israeli businesses in villages were burned, and Jewish bystanders were injured on roads.[5] Demonstrators also damaged symbols of state authority and Jewish-owned businesses.[13]

Police used live ammunition and rubber bullets to disperse demonstrations, especially in northern Israel.[14] Later testimony described police, including snipers, firing live ammunition into crowds despite earlier police denials.[14] The commission found that some responses escalated to lethal ammunition without an objective danger that justified it.[3] It also found weaknesses in reporting and documentation, failures to learn from earlier incidents, and no reasonable justification for the failure to report the use of sniper fire to the political leadership.[3]

The commission concluded that deaths during the early disturbances intensified the unrest.[3] Government and Arab-sector leaders began taking steps to moderate and end the confrontations after the deaths on October 2, but five citizens were killed in subsequent riots.[3] Demonstrations continued through October 4, with further violence occurring later in the period covered by the inquiry.[11] A retrospective account described a second wave beginning on October 7 and ending on October 10.[10]

On October 6, Palestinian officials declared a “Day of Rage.”[5] At the Temple Mount, Israeli police relinquished their presence while Waqf guards and Palestinian Authority security personnel took responsibility for security checks.[5] Demonstrators subsequently took over and set fire to a police station inside the compound, prompting the evacuation of worshippers from the Western Wall Plaza.[5]

On October 7, Jewish driver Bechor Jean was struck by a stone thrown at his car near Jisr al-Zarqa and later died in hospital.[9] Jewish attacks on Arabs also intensified during the disturbances.[8][13] Approximately 200 Jewish Israelis attacked Arab homes in Upper Nazareth on October 7, followed by an attack involving approximately 1,000 Jewish Israelis on Arab homes in Nazareth on October 8.[8] Other incidents targeted Arab homes, businesses employing Arabs, and mosques.[8]

At the boundary between Nazareth and Nazareth Illit on October 8, police fired tear gas and rubber bullets at Arab residents during violence involving Jewish rioters.[9] Omar Akawi and Wissam Yazbek were killed.[9] The 2001 human-rights account described police arriving late, positioning themselves between the groups, and firing live ammunition, rubber bullets, and tear gas at Arab citizens; it recorded two deaths and approximately 50 injuries.[14] The attackers were alleged to have been angered by Hezbollah's kidnapping of three Israeli soldiers and the attack on Joseph's Tomb.[14]

Religious sites were among the targets of subsequent violence, although religion was generally not a component of the demonstrations.[6] In Sha'faram, youths slightly damaged an ancient synagogue while protesting police actions in nearby towns.[6] The mayor and other Arab residents tried unsuccessfully to protect it, and the mayor later publicly apologized to Jewish Israelis.[6] A Jewish crowd moderately damaged a mosque in Tiberias, while police prevented attempted attacks on mosques in Jaffa and Akko.[6]

The commission recorded 14 deaths in the October events it investigated: 13 Israeli citizens and one resident of the Gaza Strip.[1] Its summary identified the Israeli citizens as 12 Arabs and one Jew.[3] Many others were injured, with the 2001 human-rights report recording approximately 300 injuries among Arab citizens during the demonstrations and the religious-freedom report giving a figure above 300.[6][14] Demonstrators and police officers were both among those injured during the unrest.[10]

04Aftermath

In November 2000, Barak's government established the Or Commission to investigate the events, their causes, and the police response, and to recommend measures to the government.[3][14] Appointed after public outcry, the commission was chaired by Supreme Court Justice Theodore Or and included District Court Judge Hashem Khatib and Middle East scholar Shimon Shamir.[15] Its mandate encompassed the conduct of organizers, participants, and security forces, rather than police actions alone.[1]

Hearings began on February 19, 2001.[15] By the end of that year, the commission had held more than 50 sessions and heard more than 330 witnesses.[14] Police witnesses described inadequate preparation for violent demonstrations, confusion over the chain of command, and instances in which local commanders had not been informed that snipers were deployed.[14] Doctors testified that rubber-coated steel bullets fired from close range apparently caused several deaths.[14]

The inquiry conducted site visits and compiled 4,275 exhibits.[1] The commission's introduction reports that its material collectors took about 500 witness statements and that the commission heard 434 testimonies, including 58 from witnesses who had also appeared in the first stage.[1] Ynet separately reported 349 witnesses in 66 first-stage sessions, 89 witnesses in 25 second-stage sessions, and 14 warning letters to individuals whose conduct was under examination.[15] The commission issued its findings in September 2003, criticizing government policy, police conduct, and the actions of some Arab leaders.[16][17]

For the commission, responsibility extended beyond the immediate operational decisions of police officers.[3] It found that successive governments had failed to address the problems of Arab citizens and had allocated resources unequally.[16] It also concluded that some Arab leaders contributed to the depth and intensity of the events by failing to channel demands exclusively through legitimate democratic means and by not taking steps to prevent demonstrations from becoming violent.[3]

The commission criticized Barak for insufficient attention to developments in Arab society, inadequate advance preparation, and insufficient action during the first two days to prevent or limit deadly force.[3][17] It made no operative recommendation concerning him.[17] Public Security Minister Shlomo Ben-Ami was faulted for failing to ensure adequate police preparation and address the risks of rubber-coated bullets; the commission recommended that he not again serve in that ministerial role.[3][17]

Police Commissioner Yehuda Wilk was criticized for failing to prepare and supervise the force adequately, and the commission recommended against his future appointment to a senior internal-security position.[17] It similarly recommended that Northern District commander Alik Ron not hold a future senior internal-security command or management post.[3][17] Its findings described inadequate district preparation and management under Ron, as well as unjustified sniper fire against stone-throwers in Umm al-Fahm, contrary to police instructions.[17] At least seven people were hit and one died in that shooting, and the commission also attributed sniper fire in Nazareth to Ron.[17]

The inquiry recommended dismissing Deputy Commissioner Moshe Waldman and Chief Inspector Guy Reiff.[17] In Reiff's case, it found that unjustified live fire near Sakhnin caused two civilian deaths and other injuries.[17] The commission recommended that the Police Investigation Department examine specified incidents, leaving competent authorities to decide whether criminal or other proceedings were warranted.[3] Its findings and recommendations were not criminal convictions.[3]

The commission also assigned responsibility to Sheikh Raed Salah and Knesset members Azmi Bishara and Abd al-Malik Dahamshe.[17] It found that Salah had repeatedly encouraged violence and contributed to escalation by speaking of a planned “massacre” at al-Aqsa, and that Bishara and Dahamshe had conveyed support for violence.[17] No operative recommendations were made against these figures because they did not hold executive positions.[17]

Policing recommendations included better training, equipment, riot-control doctrine, communication, reporting, and relations with Arab communities.[3] The commission stated that live fire, including sniper fire, was not a method of crowd dispersal and that potentially lethal force should be restricted to a real and immediate threat to life.[3][3] It recommended withdrawing rubber-coated bullets from police use because of their risks and criticized the excessive reliance on them during the disturbances.[3][7]

The broader recommendations made substantive equality for Arab citizens a principal state objective requiring government leadership and the prime minister's personal involvement.[16] They called for programs addressing gaps in education, housing, industrial development, employment, public services, and budgets, together with equitable land allocation and attention to Bedouin living conditions.[3][16] Police were urged to understand that the Arab public as a whole was not an enemy, while Arab leaders were urged to reject violence as a means of achieving political aims.[16] The commission emphasized both the right to demonstrate and the absence of any right to attack people or engage in violent riots.[3]

Operational responsibilities also changed after the events.[4] The government assigned the Israel Security Agency responsibility for intelligence concerning nationalist unrest, while police retained responsibility for intelligence on public-order matters unrelated to nationalist activity.[4] During the first month after the riots, approximately 1,000 people were arrested in Arab and Jewish localities: 660 Arabs and 340 Jews.[14] Of those arrested, 79 percent of Arabs and 21 percent of Jews were indicted, while 72 percent of Arabs and 11 percent of Jews were detained without bond.[14]

In 2005, the Police Investigation Department closed the cases against officers involved in fatal shootings, citing insufficient evidence in some cases and inability to identify or apprehend responsible officers in others.[18] The department's explanation emphasized the criminal requirement of proof beyond reasonable doubt, lost or damaged scene evidence, difficulties reaching locations safely during the unrest, and limited cooperation by some witnesses and families, including refusals of autopsies.[18] The decision left the fatal-shooting cases against police officers without indictments.[18] In 2019, Barak apologized for the deaths of Arab demonstrators and said he bore responsibility for events during his premiership.[19]

05Historiography and Legacy

The October events reduced contact between Jewish and Arab communities and increased distrust and hostility.[3] The commission described the status of Arab citizens and the state's treatment of them as an urgent domestic issue, but concluded that the rupture was not a point of no return and that peaceful coexistence remained feasible.[3] The events were a severe blow to Jewish-Arab relations, with consequences extending beyond the immediate period of demonstrations and clashes.[6][9]

Historical research has placed October 2000 alongside Land Day in 1976 as one of two exceptional large-scale violent confrontations between Arab citizens and security forces since Israel's founding.[7] Research on policing has also treated the events as a period of over-policing, contrasting the lethal police response in 2000 with later concerns about under-policing in Arab communities.[20] Assessments of the commission's longer-term influence have concluded that its recommendations remained largely unheeded and that governing institutions continued to lack clear goals and a strategy for addressing relations with Arab citizens.[21]

Interpretations differ over the relative importance of national identification, religious concerns, socioeconomic inequality, leadership, and policing.[13] Arab narratives have emphasized discriminatory Israeli policies, while Jewish narratives have emphasized the growing identification of Arab citizens with the Palestinian national struggle across the Green Line.[13] The commission's findings encompassed both structural discrimination and the political radicalization and leadership conduct it identified.[3] Its account therefore addressed long-term conditions alongside the immediate sequence of demonstrations, police responses, and deaths.[3]

Questions about prior planning and responsibility remain distinct from the documented occurrence of violence.[7] The precise degree of planning by Arab leaders is uncertain, and developments on the ground, including demonstrators' actions and police responses, affected how events unfolded.[7] The later criminal-investigation decisions also differed from the commission's findings in prominent cases involving sniper fire ordered by Alik Ron and shooting attributed to Guy Reiff.[18] The commission's inquiry findings and the evidentiary requirements for criminal proceedings were consequently not interchangeable.[3][18]

Published accounts also use different casualty categories and, in some cases, different totals.[22] The commission's own breakdown was 12 Arab Israeli citizens, one Jewish Israeli citizen, and one Gaza resident, whereas some contemporary human-rights accounts described 13 Arab citizens killed by police.[3][8] Other accounts distinguish 12 Arab Israelis and one Palestinian killed by police from the Jewish motorist killed separately, while a later retrospective reported 14 demonstrators killed in police clashes in addition to the Jewish driver.[19][22] These formulations should not be treated as identical counts or classifications.[22]

Sources

  1. 1Or Commission, Introduction, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  2. 2U.S. Department of State, Israel and the occupied territories, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  3. 3Jewish Virtual Library, Israeli Arabs: The Official Summation of the Or Commission Report, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  4. 4Institute for National Security Studies, Missed Signals that Led to a Strategic Surprise: Israeli Arab Riots in 2021, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  5. 5Jerusalem Institute for Policy Research, The Eroding Status-Quo, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  6. 6U.S. Department of State, Israel and the occupied territories, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  7. 7Institute for National Security Studies, Historical Study, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  8. 8Jewish Virtual Library, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices - 2000, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  9. 9Ynet, Red October, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  10. 10Ynet, 20 years have passed, and the Arab public refuses to forgive: “Whoever gave the order to shoot is a war criminal”, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  11. 11Ynetnews, October Riots, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  12. 12The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, The Israeli Arabs: Defending al-Aqsa or Fighting for Equality?, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  13. 13Jewish Virtual Library, Israel Studies An Anthology : Israel and its Arab Minority, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  14. 14U.S. Department of State, Israel and the occupied territories, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  15. 15Ynet, The Or Commission: The end of the testimonies, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  16. 16Ynet, The Or Commission: Erase the stain of discrimination against Israel’s Arabs, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  17. 17Ynet, The Or Commission: Ben-Ami, Wilk, and Alik Ron are disqualified from security positions, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  18. 18Ynet, The Police Investigation Department decided: No one is guilty in the October events, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  19. 19The Times of Israel, In Nights of Arab-Jewish Violence, Memories of October 2000, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  20. 20Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, To Be Served and Protected: Israeli Arab Citizens and the Police, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  21. 21Jerusalem Institute for Policy Research, Publications, accessed on November 2, 2026.
  22. 22Ynet, 12 years since the October riots: “We will punish the murderers”, accessed on November 2, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What were the October 2000 protests in Israel?

    The October 2000 protests in Israel were a wave of demonstrations, riots, and Jewish-Arab clashes that took place principally from October 1 to 10, amid the beginning of the Second Intifada. The events included roadblocks, attacks on civilians and security forces, lethal police shootings, and Jewish attacks on Arabs. The Or Commission recorded 14 deaths: 12 Arab citizens of Israel, one Jewish citizen, and one resident of the Gaza Strip.

  • What led to the October 2000 protests in Israel?

    The protests took place amid the beginning of the Second Intifada and followed longstanding disputes over discrimination, unequal resource allocation, land, and public services for Arab citizens of Israel. The Or Commission also identified increased identification with the Palestinian struggle, the growth of Islamic politics, and political and ideological radicalization as contributing factors. Warnings of possible widespread unrest had been received before October, but the commission found that police and political authorities were inadequately prepared.

  • What happened during the October 2000 protests in Israel?

    Demonstrations and clashes spread across towns and villages, with roadblocks, stone-throwing, attacks on police stations, property damage, and confrontations between protesters and police. Police used live ammunition and rubber bullets, and the Or Commission found that some use of lethal ammunition was unjustified. Violence also included attacks by Jewish Israelis on Arab homes, businesses, and mosques. The commission recorded 14 deaths in the events it investigated.

  • What did the Or Commission conclude about the October 2000 protests?

    The Or Commission concluded that government handling of Arab citizens had been “primarily neglectful and discriminatory,” and criticized police preparedness and conduct as well as actions by some Arab leaders. It recommended greater equality in state policy, improvements in policing and relations with Arab communities, and measures to address gaps in areas including education, housing, employment, and public services. Its findings and recommendations were not criminal convictions.

  • What happened to the criminal cases against police officers involved in fatal shootings during the protests?

    In 2005, the Police Investigation Department closed the cases against officers involved in fatal shootings, and no officers were indicted in those cases. The department cited insufficient evidence in some cases and an inability to identify or apprehend responsible officers in others. It also pointed to lost or damaged scene evidence, difficulties reaching locations safely, and limited cooperation by some witnesses and families.

  • How did the October 2000 protests affect Jewish-Arab relations in Israel?

    The October 2000 events severely damaged Jewish-Arab relations, reducing contact between the communities and increasing distrust and hostility. The Or Commission described the rupture as serious but concluded that it was not a point of no return and that peaceful coexistence remained feasible. Historical assessments have also concluded that the commission’s recommendations remained largely unheeded.