← All articles

Total current articles · 5,248

Nili

Published

01In brief

Nili was a secret, pro-British Jewish espionage organization active in Ottoman-ruled Palestine and Syria during the First World War, from 1915 to 1917. Led by Aaron Aaronsohn, Avshalom Feinberg, Sarah Aaronsohn, and Yosef Lishansky, it gathered intelligence to assist a British conquest of the region; Sarah directed a core of about forty agents and a wider circle of supporters and informers. Its work combined military intelligence, communication with British headquarters in Egypt, and the transfer of financial relief to the Jewish population. Ottoman authorities exposed the network in autumn 1917, leading to arrests, torture, and executions, while its contribution and the risks it had imposed on the Jewish community shaped a long debate over its legacy.

02Overview

Nili sought to replace Ottoman rule with British control by supplying information that could assist a British military advance into Palestine.[1] Its founders came from the Jewish agricultural settlements, and many were locally born young people whose political outlook reflected disappointment with Ottoman treatment of the Jewish population.[1] Fear that Jews might suffer a fate comparable to that of the Armenians strengthened their belief that Jewish prospects depended on a British victory.[1] Espionage, rather than an open revolt, became their chosen means of intervention in the war.[1]

The organization linked agricultural settlements and an experimental station at Atlit with British intelligence headquarters in Cairo.[1] Its members collected military, political, and economic information, drawing partly on the freedom of movement available to people working on agricultural and locust-control projects.[1] Aaron Aaronsohn supplied scientific expertise, geographical knowledge, and contacts with British officials, while Sarah Aaronsohn coordinated operations in Palestine and the Lebanon area during much of the network’s active period.[1][2] British official documents referred to the network as the “A. Organization.”[1]

Nili’s purposes extended beyond the collection of military intelligence: its members also publicized the persecution of local Jews and helped carry relief money to a population suffering hunger, destitution, and displacement.[1][4] These activities brought the organization into contact with representatives of the Yishuv, the Jewish community in Palestine, whose leaders nevertheless feared that clandestine cooperation with Britain might provoke Ottoman reprisals.[1] Nili thus operated both as an intelligence network and as a group seeking a political voice within the broader pro-British Zionist movement.[1]

03Origins and History

In January 1915, Ottoman authorities arrested Avshalom Feinberg and other young men in Hadera on a false accusation of contact with British boats.[1] Feinberg worked at Aaron Aaronsohn’s agricultural experimental station at Atlit, and after his release he proposed a Jewish revolt supported by Britain.[1] Aaronsohn rejected an uprising as impractical but accepted the possibility of helping the British through espionage.[1] Another account of these early approaches records Ottoman questioning of Hadera residents and the subsequent arrest of thirteen people, after which Feinberg discussed providing concrete assistance to the British with Levi Yitzchak Schneersohn.[3]

The network drew on relationships already established among families and young people in the agricultural settlements.[5] Feinberg and Alexander Aaronsohn had founded the Gideonim in 1913 as an association intended to protect settlement residents.[5] Early Nili recruits included Feinberg’s Hadera friends Liuba Schneersohn and Nisan Rotman, his brother-in-law Nahum Wilbushwitz, and his cousins Eitan and Na’aman Belkind; Aaron Aaronsohn subsequently brought several members of his own family into the undertaking.[5] Recruitment also extended to Zikhron Ya’akov and Rishon le-Zion, as well as Hadera.[1]

Sarah Aaronsohn joined Nili in November 1915, after returning from Constantinople, where she had lived with her husband between 1914 and 1915.[4][6] On her return journey to Zikhron Ya’akov she encountered reports of Ottoman killings of Armenians.[6] She had studied agronomy and botany and assisted Aaron at his experimental farm in Atlit, experience that preceded her intelligence work and extensive travel around the country.[7] From at least late 1916 until her capture in October 1917, she coordinated and largely conducted Nili’s activities in Palestine and the Lebanon area.[2]

Establishing dependable communication with Britain was a prolonged undertaking.[1] Alexander Aaronsohn’s approach met with disapproval from the British Arab Bureau in Cairo, while Feinberg’s early attempts did not produce a lasting connection.[1] Feinberg traveled to Egypt to offer assistance and returned in November 1915 reporting that the British had agreed to make contact at Atlit Beach.[3] A contact there is dated to March 16, 1916, after which members gathered information about Ottoman army movements, preparations against a British attack, and plans affecting the Land of Israel.[3] The agricultural experimental station served as their operational base, but a reliable channel for transmitting the accumulated material remained difficult to maintain.[1][3]

Aaron Aaronsohn eventually traveled through Germany and neutral Denmark to London, where he met British statesmen and military officials.[1] He was then sent to Cairo as an intelligence adviser and helped plan the British offensive against Palestine.[1] His position connected the network’s local intelligence gathering to British military planning in Egypt, while the operatives remaining in Palestine continued to face the practical problem of passing information across the front.[1]

In January 1917, Feinberg and Yosef Lishansky attempted to reach Egypt overland through Sinai, disguised as Bedouin.[1] They were attacked near the British front: Feinberg was killed, while the wounded Lishansky reached British lines and joined Aaronsohn.[1] In February, a British boat brought Lishansky back to the coast, and he helped establish contact between the Atlit intelligence center and British intelligence in Egypt.[1] Sea communication continued for several months, allowing the British to receive the organization’s reports together with Aaronsohn’s knowledge of local geography and the Ottoman command.[1]

The name Nili was selected in 1917 when Aaron Aaronsohn and a British officer asked Schneersohn to suggest a name for their undertaking.[3] Schneersohn opened a Bible and chose “Netzach Yisrael Lo Yeshaker,” whose initials formed N.I.L.I.; the phrase comes from 1 Samuel 15:29 and also served as the organization’s password.[1][3] One account renders it as “The Eternity of Israel will not deceive” and preserves the British officer’s joking response: “She must be a lovely girl, this Nili.”[3] Schneersohn recorded the naming incident in a diary later kept at the Central Zionist Archives.[5]

Exposure followed in September 1917, when Ottoman authorities captured a carrier pigeon sent from Atlit toward Egypt that provided evidence of espionage.[1] Na’aman Belkind was also captured and interrogated, giving the authorities information about the network’s operations.[1] Nili members did not immediately leave: they hoped to obtain Belkind’s release and feared that their own departure might bring disaster upon the Yishuv.[3] Sarah remained despite advice from British intelligence to escape by sea and a request from Aaron that she flee to Egypt.[4][6]

On October 1, Ottoman soldiers surrounded Zikhron Ya’akov and arrested numerous people, including Sarah Aaronsohn; searches extended to other villages.[1] Sarah endured interrogation and torture without disclosing information about her colleagues or the organization.[7] On October 5, before a planned transfer to prison, she was taken to her family home, where she retrieved a concealed pistol and shot herself; she died from her wounds several days later.[8] A surviving fragment presented as part of her suicide note reads, “As heroes we died and did not confess.”[4]

Lishansky escaped the initial arrests and sought refuge among former associates in Ha-Shomer.[1] Its committee decided that he should die if his capture threatened to expose the wider Jewish community to disaster, and emissaries wounded him in an attempted assassination.[1] He escaped again but was subsequently captured by Bedouin and handed over to the Ottoman authorities.[1] Belkind and Lishansky were sentenced to death and executed in Damascus on December 16, 1917.[1] Reuven Schwartz, another Nili member, was found hanged while in detention.[3]

Most prisoners were eventually released after interventions by Jewish leaders and secret German assistance, but twelve received prison sentences of one to three years and thirty were conscripted.[1] Other arrests reached beyond the principal operatives: Sonia Belkind, a physician who had cared for people expelled from Tel Aviv, was detained, while Eitan Belkind was sentenced to death but escaped after Avraham Herzfeld bribed a Turkish guard.[6] The exposure dispersed the intelligence network, and its remaining political organization dissolved rapidly after Aaron Aaronsohn died in an air accident in 1919.[1]

04Practice and Operations

Sarah Aaronsohn managed approximately forty core agents, a broader circle of supporters and informers, and the organization’s finances.[2] She assessed incoming information, decoded and sifted reports, encoded material for onward transmission, and communicated with British intelligence headquarters in Cairo.[2][4] In 1917, after Feinberg’s death and Aaron’s departure from Palestine, she and Yosef Lishansky directed local operations.[7] Her responsibilities included maintaining contact with Ottoman authorities who remained unaware of the underground until its final months, as well as dealing with an increasingly hostile community in her home settlement.[4]

Her own correspondence expressed a strong personal commitment to the work.[9] In a letter discussing its dangers, she wrote: “I have a large role in the work here, and if we have to endanger ourselves, my dear one, I think not of it. The work is dear and holy to me.”[9] She supervised intelligence gathering while Aaron was away and bore responsibility for communicating with the British.[9] Postwar Hebrew narratives sometimes framed that leadership principally through her family relationships, whereas British and Ottoman intelligence sources did not treat her merely as a substitute for her brother.[4]

The agricultural experimental station at Atlit provided both a collection point for reports and a coastal link to British vessels.[1] Some operatives joined Aaronsohn’s locust-control staff, which enabled them to travel around the country and enter military camps.[1] The Jewish Review of Books emphasizes the importance of Aaronsohn’s scientific standing, describing how Ottoman governor Djemal Pasha had permitted him to travel widely to assess and combat a major locust plague.[10] That review argues that his effective work against the plague and extensive geographical knowledge helped make him valuable to British intelligence.[10]

Nili gathered information about Ottoman troop movements, military readiness, and the authorities’ intentions concerning Palestine.[3] Its reports also covered fortifications, railways, routes through the desert, water sources, and weather, including details concerning Beersheba and the Negev.[11] These subjects addressed both the enemy’s dispositions and the terrain through which an advancing British force would have to move.[11] Military intelligence was collected alongside political and economic material, rather than as an entirely separate undertaking.[1]

A Jewish Review of Books discussion describes operatives who worked as doctors, farmers, and merchants using their occupations and local familiarity to approach Ottoman positions.[12] The review credits them with mapping forces, training, equipment, roads, bridges, and fortifications constructed by German engineers.[12] It offers two specific examples: a map of Jerusalem’s Ottoman defenses made by a Turkish army engineer recruited by Sarah, and a report detailing the number and capabilities of aircraft being sent to the Gaza–Beersheba front, including speeds and machine-gun capacities.[12] The review argues that the aircraft report gave the British time to reinforce their own air strength and that Nili’s information was also used to check intelligence from other sources.[12]

Aaron’s work in Cairo and Sarah’s activity in Palestine formed complementary parts of the undertaking.[1][2] The Jewish Review of Books portrays Aaron as editing and interpreting reports and coordinating with General Edmund Allenby and his staff, while Sarah recruited sources, reactivated contacts who had ceased reporting, and visited Damascus to listen to German officers supporting the Ottoman war effort.[12] Another review describes reports on bases, installations, armaments, logistics, troop concentrations, and the terrain relevant to a British offensive, with Zikhron Ya’akov and Atlit serving as bases and Cairo as the destination for the intelligence.[13]

Maritime communication initially depended on a British vessel visiting the Atlit coast and exchanging signals with the shore.[11] Operatives used signal lights to communicate with a British frigate at roughly two-week intervals; when the frigate stopped coming, they relied on homing pigeons.[11] Schneersohn acted as a contact officer between the Atlit group and the British, spending periods aboard a ship or at Egyptian bases deciphering and translating reports.[3] This combination of coastal rendezvous, encoded messages, and pigeon communications carried intelligence out of Ottoman territory, but a captured pigeon also furnished the authorities with evidence of the operation.[1][11]

Relief work developed alongside espionage, particularly as wartime disruption intensified the needs of the Jewish population.[1] Nili helped people expelled from Jaffa and Tel Aviv by Ottoman authorities in spring 1917, and Aaron publicized their persecution, which was subsequently stopped.[1] Members also assisted the transfer of financial aid after the United States broke off relations with Turkey in April 1917.[1] Sarah and Lishansky visited Aaron in Egypt and returned with £2,000 in gold coins for the Yishuv’s political committee.[1]

Sarah supervised the movement of American Jewish funds converted into gold while continuing her intelligence duties.[2] The money was intended to relieve hunger, destitution, and displacement among local Jews.[4] Relief activity also affected Nili’s relations with communal representatives: the organization sought recognition from Yishuv leaders and Zionist figures abroad, and attitudes toward it shifted after its assistance efforts.[1] At a September 1917 meeting in London, Aaron persuaded Chaim Weizmann and colleagues of Nili’s importance within the pro-British part of the Zionist movement.[1]

05Significance and Commemoration

General Edmund Allenby later credited Aaron Aaronsohn with a central role in organizing intelligence behind Ottoman lines, writing: “He was mainly responsible for the formation of my Field Intelligence organisation behind Turkish lines.”[10] The British Army recognized Nili’s contribution, and most surviving members received honors.[3] Its assistance to the British conquest also formed part of the wider activity of the pro-British Zionist movement during the war years of 1914–1918.[1]

Nili supplied information relevant to the British advance through the south of the country, including desert routes, water supplies, fortifications, and troop movements around Beersheba and the Negev.[11] Its information contributed to the October 1917 attack on Beersheba, which opened the way into central Palestine and toward Jerusalem.[11] Aaron’s contribution included geographical expertise as well as the intelligence produced by the network’s agents.[1] These practical subjects connected the organization’s agricultural and scientific experience to the requirements of a military campaign.[1][11]

The network also sought influence beyond its intelligence relationship with Britain.[1] It approached Ha-Shomer and other groups and pursued recognition from Jewish representatives, attempting to secure a broader place within the Yishuv and the Zionist movement.[1] As an effort by locally born young people from agricultural settlements to establish an independent political movement, however, it failed to attract a broad social base.[1] Aaron’s death in 1919 was followed by the rapid dissolution of that political undertaking.[1]

Commemoration of Sarah Aaronsohn developed before Nili’s eventual official recognition.[2] Annual pilgrimages to her grave began in 1935, and she was idealized as the “hero of Nili,” sometimes represented as a soldier-saint or a Jewish Joan of Arc.[2] Her sister Rebecca devoted herself to establishing an archive at the family home and founded a museum commemorating Nili and the Aaronsohn family in 1956.[14] The family home thereby became a site for preserving the organization’s records and memory.[14]

The public standing of Nili changed during the 1960s, particularly after the discovery of Avshalom Feinberg’s remains in Sinai following the Six-Day War.[3] Researcher Shlomo Ben-Elkana identified the location using information supplied by Feinberg’s sister Tzila, and Feinberg was reburied in a state ceremony on Mount Herzl on November 29, 1967.[6] A book based on Schneersohn’s diaries was also published in 1967, adding another body of testimony to public discussion of the network.[3] After the war, Sarah and Nili received official recognition and were incorporated into a state-sponsored culture of heroism.[2]

Records preserved from individual members also illuminate relationships within the underground.[15] Schneersohn, who suggested its name and served as an intermediary with the British, left a notebook containing love poems addressed to Sarah that apparently were never shown to her.[15] His diaries preserved the naming episode, while Sarah’s letters recorded her understanding of the work and its dangers.[5][9] Together with the archive created by Rebecca, these materials became part of the surviving record through which the organization and its members were remembered.[9][14]

06Controversies

Fear of Ottoman reprisals was the central contemporary objection to Nili’s activity.[1] Jewish communal leaders worried that discovery of the network could endanger the entire Yishuv, and the formal leadership distanced itself from the organization.[1][4] After its exposure, many Jews regarded the surviving operatives as impetuous young people who had put the community at risk, in contrast to the recognition they received from the British.[3] Public argument about their conduct and commemoration continued into the 1960s.[16]

The extent of Nili’s military and diplomatic influence has also produced differing interpretations.[12] A Jewish Review of Books review argues that Allenby’s flanking movement toward Beersheba depended heavily on Nili intelligence and notes Aaron’s advocacy of that approach.[13] Former Mossad commander Efraim Halevy offered a broader assessment, crediting Nili with intelligence vital to the conquest and to securing British support, and noting Aaron’s presence alongside Chaim Weizmann during British cabinet deliberations over the Balfour Declaration.[17] These assessments concern the degree of Nili’s causal influence, rather than merely the fact that it supplied intelligence.[13][17]

Historical accounts differ over the relative roles of Feinberg and Aaron in initiating the network, the interpretation of Sarah’s leadership, and the motives of supporters and opponents.[5][12] The Jewish Review of Books cautions that biographies and histories contain factual contradictions and competing interpretations.[12] Allegations that Lishansky had killed Feinberg were countered by the later discovery of Feinberg’s remains and corroboration of Lishansky’s account of the Sinai attack, as related in another review.[13] These disputes shaped the organization’s reputation but did not erase the subsequent official recognition of Nili and its members.[2][13]

Sources

  1. 1Jewish Virtual Library, Nili, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  2. 2My Jewish Learning, Sarah Aaronsohn, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  3. 3National Library of Israel, The Librarians, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  4. 4Israel Forever Foundation, Heroes of Israel Purim Costume Ideas, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  5. 5Globes, Nili, Come Home, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  6. 6Ynet, Feinberg family: Back to first days of Zionism – part 2, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  7. 7Ynet, 5 Sites and Routes Following Prominent Women in the History of Zionism, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  8. 8Center for Israel Education, Spy Sarah Aaronsohn Dies, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  9. 9National Library of Israel, The Librarians, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  10. 10Jewish Review of Books, Islamic Jihad, Zionism, and Espionage in the Great War, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  11. 11Jewish Virtual Library, Jewish Defense Organizations: The NILI Spy Ring, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  12. 12Jewish Review of Books, To Spy Out the Land, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  13. 13Jewish Review of Books, Wisdom and Wars, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  14. 14Ynet, Women's Help: A Tour Following Female Leaders and Fighters in the Land of Israel, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  15. 15Ynet, Love in the Underground, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  16. 16The Jerusalem Post, Israel budgets NIS 10m. to keep alive memory of Nili spy ring, accessed on October 31, 2026.
  17. 17World Jewish Congress, Israeli spies helped pave the way for Balfour Declaration, says ex-Mossad chief, accessed on October 31, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What was Nili?

    Nili was a secret, pro-British Jewish espionage organization active in Ottoman-ruled Palestine and Syria from 1915 to 1917. Led by Aaron Aaronsohn, Avshalom Feinberg, Sarah Aaronsohn, and Yosef Lishansky, it gathered intelligence to assist a British conquest of the region and also helped transfer financial relief to the Jewish population.

  • Why did Nili oppose Ottoman rule?

    Nili’s founders believed Jewish prospects depended on a British victory, following disappointment with Ottoman treatment of the Jewish population. Fear that Jews might suffer a fate comparable to that of the Armenians strengthened that view. Rather than launch an open revolt, the group chose espionage as its means of helping Britain replace Ottoman rule.

  • How did Nili send intelligence to the British?

    Nili connected its agricultural settlements and experimental station at Atlit with British intelligence headquarters in Cairo. Members initially exchanged signals with a British vessel off the coast, and later used homing pigeons when the vessel stopped coming. After Yosef Lishansky returned from Egypt in February 1917, he helped establish contact between Atlit and British intelligence.

  • What intelligence did Nili collect?

    Nili gathered information about Ottoman troop movements, military readiness, fortifications, railways, desert routes, water sources, and weather. Its reports included details about Beersheba and the Negev, as well as political and economic information. Operatives used their occupations and local familiarity to approach Ottoman positions and report on forces and military infrastructure.

  • How did Nili assist Jewish civilians during the war?

    Nili publicized the persecution of local Jews and helped provide relief to a population suffering hunger, destitution, and displacement. Members assisted people expelled from Jaffa and Tel Aviv in spring 1917 and helped transfer financial aid after the United States broke off relations with Turkey. Sarah Aaronsohn and Yosef Lishansky returned from Egypt with £2,000 in gold coins for the Yishuv’s political committee.

  • How was Nili exposed and what happened to its members?

    Ottoman authorities exposed Nili in September 1917 after capturing a carrier pigeon sent from Atlit toward Egypt and capturing Na’aman Belkind, who provided information about the network. On October 1, soldiers surrounded Zikhron Ya’akov and arrested numerous people, including Sarah Aaronsohn. Belkind and Lishansky were executed in Damascus on December 16, 1917; Sarah died from wounds several days after shooting herself during her captivity.

  • How did Nili’s legacy change over time?

    Many Jews initially viewed Nili’s surviving operatives as impetuous young people who had put the Yishuv at risk, while the British recognized their contribution. Sarah Aaronsohn was commemorated from 1935, and a museum dedicated to Nili and the Aaronsohn family opened in 1956. After the Six-Day War, Sarah and Nili received official recognition and became part of a state-sponsored culture of heroism.