← All articles

Total current articles · 5,097

Israel of Bamberg

Published

01In brief

Israel of Bamberg was a tosafist and rabbi active in the middle of the thirteenth century. A pupil of Samuel of Bamberg, he succeeded his teacher as rabbi of Bamberg. His Tosafot to Shabbat and Avodah Zarah are no longer extant, but references and quotations preserve evidence of these works. Tosafot associated with his students were also frequently cited by Bezalel Ashkenazi.

02Early Life

Israel’s early life is known chiefly through his education. He studied under the tosafist Samuel ben Baruch of Bamberg, whose teachings later became the primary basis of Israel’s own Tosafot; Israel eventually succeeded Samuel as rabbi of Bamberg.[1]

03Career

Israel studied under Samuel of Bamberg before succeeding him in the local rabbinate.[1] He was active in the middle of the thirteenth century.[1] His own Tosafot relied primarily on Samuel’s teachings, although he also quoted Eleazar of Erfurt on one occasion.[1]

His writings included Tosafot to the tractates Shabbat and Avodah Zarah.[1] Benjacob argued that these works were directed to Alfasi rather than, as was customary for Tosafot, to the Talmudic text itself.[1]

04Legacy

Although Israel’s Tosafot to Shabbat and Avodah Zarah are no longer extant, they are mentioned in the Mordekhai and quoted by a fifteenth-century Italian codifier in manuscript Adler 2717, folio 308.[1]

Bezalel Ashkenazi frequently cites the Tosefot Talmidei R. Yisrael—“Tosafot of R. Israel’s students”—in his Shitah Mekubbe’et on Bava Kama.[1] These citations preserve a record of Tosafot associated with Israel’s students alongside the references to his own writings.[1]

05Controversies

Israel’s identification with Israel ben Uri Shraga, another name associated with Tosafot cited in the Mordekhai, is disputed: Eckstein regarded them as the same person, while Kohen considered them distinct.[2]

The separate biographical entry for Israel ben Uri Shraga describes him as a pupil of Samuel of Bamberg who was called around 1250 to succeed Samuel as rabbi of Bamberg.[3] Because the identification itself remains disputed, these overlapping details cannot be treated as proof that the two names refer to one person.[2][3]

Sources

  1. 1Encyclopedia.com, Israel of Bamberg, accessed on November 19, 2026.
  2. 2Jewish Encyclopedia, ISRAEL OF BAMBERG - JewishEncyclopedia.com, accessed on November 19, 2026.
  3. 3Jewish Encyclopedia, ISRAEL BEN URI SHRAGA - JewishEncyclopedia.com, accessed on November 19, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • Who was Israel of Bamberg?

    Israel of Bamberg was a tosafist and rabbi active in the middle of the thirteenth century. A pupil of Samuel of Bamberg, he succeeded his teacher as rabbi of Bamberg. His Tosafot to Shabbat and Avodah Zarah are no longer extant, but later references and quotations preserve evidence of them.

  • Who taught Israel of Bamberg, and whose teachings shaped his Tosafot?

    Israel of Bamberg studied under the tosafist Samuel ben Baruch of Bamberg, whose teachings later became the primary basis of Israel’s Tosafot. Israel also quoted Eleazar of Erfurt on one occasion.

  • What did Israel of Bamberg write?

    Israel of Bamberg wrote Tosafot to the tractates Shabbat and Avodah Zarah. Benjacob argued that these works were directed to Alfasi rather than to the Talmudic text itself, as was customary for Tosafot.

  • How have Israel of Bamberg’s writings survived?

    Israel of Bamberg’s Tosafot to Shabbat and Avodah Zarah are no longer extant, but they are mentioned in the Mordekhai and quoted by a fifteenth-century Italian codifier in manuscript Adler 2717, folio 308.

  • What are the Tosefot Talmidei R. Yisrael?

    The Tosefot Talmidei R. Yisrael, meaning “Tosafot of R. Israel’s students,” are Tosafot associated with Israel of Bamberg’s students. Bezalel Ashkenazi frequently cites them in his Shitah Mekubbe’et on Bava Kama, preserving a record of this student-associated material.

  • Is Israel of Bamberg the same person as Israel ben Uri Shraga?

    The identification of Israel of Bamberg with Israel ben Uri Shraga is disputed. Eckstein regarded them as the same person, while Kohen considered them distinct. Overlapping details in their biographical accounts do not establish that the two names refer to one person.