01In brief
Israel Getzler was a historian whose scholarly work spanned the history of Russian social democracy, Soviet-era political movements, and the Jewish experience in Australia. He is best known for his political biography of Julius Martov and for his study of the Kronstadt sailors' uprising, both published by Cambridge University Press. His research into Australian Jewish history shed light on long-running debates over Jewish civic identity and political emancipation in the colonial period.
02Career and Published Works
Getzler's earliest major scholarly contribution was Martov: A Political Biography of a Russian Social Democrat, published by Cambridge University Press in 1967.[2] The work examined the life of Julius Martov, the Menshevik leader, and offered a nuanced assessment of his character and political fate. Getzler argued that Martov's honesty, strong principles, and humane nature ultimately hindered his effectiveness as a revolutionary politician, while in opposition and exile he "brilliantly personified social democracy's moral conscience."[2] Getzler returned to the subject in a 1994 article, "Iulii Martov, the Leader Who Lost His Party in 1917," published in the Slavonic and East European Review.[2]
He also contributed a new introduction to the 1975 Cambridge, Massachusetts reprint of Martov's memoir Zapiski sotsial-demokrata, first published in Berlin in 1922.[3]
A second major work in Russian and Soviet history, Kronstadt, 1917–1921: The Fate of a Soviet Democracy, was published by Cambridge University Press.[4] The book examined the Kronstadt naval base and its sailors as a case study in the fate of democratic aspirations within the early Soviet state.
On the history of Australian Jewry, Getzler authored Neither Toleration nor Favour: The Australian Chapter of Jewish Emancipation, published by Melbourne University Press in Melbourne in 1970.[1] The book provided a detailed treatment of colonial Australian debates over church and state, state aid to religious activity, and education, with particular attention to the question of Jewish political representation in the mid-nineteenth century.
03Australian Jewish Emancipation Research
Neither Toleration nor Favour documented a foundational tension within Australian Jewish public life: whether Jews constituted a distinct people or nation, and whether Jewish identity — however understood — was compatible with loyal Australian and British citizenship.[1] These questions, Getzler's research showed, were actively contested in the colonial press and community assemblies.
The book preserves two strikingly opposed voices from that era. One position, represented by a Sydney Jew writing to the Sydney Morning Herald, rejected the characterization of Jews as "a nation apart" and argued that "a British Jew would defend his country against a foreign Jew if occasion required, with as much alacrity and good feeling as a Christian could possibly do."[1] The opposing position, expressed by a Jewish communal leader in 1858, held that equal citizenship and a sense of Jewish peoplehood were not mutually exclusive: he urged his community "not to forget the cause of their brethren in other parts of the world" and reminded them that "though widely separated as individuals they were all members of one nation, united in the bonds of brotherhood."[1]
Getzler's account of these nineteenth-century debates has been drawn upon by later scholars to illuminate the roots of early twentieth-century intracommunal conflict over Zionism in Australia, which reached a climax in the 1940s.[1]
Sources
- 1Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs.
- 2Encyclopedia.com, Martov, Yuli Osipovich.
- 3Encyclopedia.com, L. Martov.
- 4Encyclopedia.com, Kronstadt Uprising.
- 5Encyclopedia.com, Baltic Fleet.