← All articles

Total current articles · 5,098

Holit

Published

01In brief

Holit is a kibbutz in the Eshkol Regional Council in southern Israel, near the southern Gaza Strip and the Gaza–Egypt border area. Sources place it approximately 1.2 to 2.6 kilometers from the Gaza border. A small agricultural community of around 150 to 200 residents before October 2023, Holit was known as a desert oasis landscaped with irrigated greenery in an otherwise arid region. The kibbutz was founded in the Yamit region of the Sinai Peninsula in the mid-to-late 1970s and relocated to its current site in 1982 following Israel's withdrawal from Sinai under the Camp David Accords. On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists invaded Holit, murdering at least thirteen civilians, abducting residents, and setting homes ablaze; the community fought largely without IDF assistance for nearly seven hours. A subsequent IDF investigation concluded that the military had failed in its mission to defend the kibbutz, while praising residents' actions as a model of civilian heroism.

02Overview

Holit lies in the Eshkol Regional Council in the southern Negev desert, near Israel's southwestern border with Gaza and the Gaza–Egypt border area.[5][1] Distances reported across sources range from approximately 1.2 to 2.6 kilometers from the Gaza perimeter fence.[2][3] The Eshkol Regional Council, of which Holit is one of fourteen kibbutzim, encompasses 32 localities and approximately 15,000 residents in total, sharing a roughly 40-kilometer border with the Gaza Strip.[7]

03History

Holit's origins lie in the Yamit region of the northeastern Sinai Peninsula, where Israel established settlements following the 1967 war.[8] Sources differ on the precise founding date. The U.S. Department of Justice and Ynet give 1977 as the year of first establishment.[5][2] Maariv states that Holit began as a Nahal military-agricultural outpost in the Rafah Salient in 1976 and attained civilian-community status in 1978.[9] The Jewish Virtual Library identifies the settlement among those in the Yammit Region of northeastern Sinai, an area that by 1981 collectively housed approximately 2,000 people across its nearby villages.[8]

Following the Camp David Accords and Israel's peace agreement with Egypt, the Israeli government prepared to evacuate its Sinai settlements. The Knesset adopted a Compensation Law on March 30, 1982, after debate over terms for displaced settlers.[8] The army began removing resisting settlers and Ma'oz militants in April 1982, and the last Israelis departed Sinai by April 25, with all of Sinai passing to Egyptian control by April 26.[8] Holit was relocated to its current position in the southern Negev near the Gaza border in 1982.[5][2]

In the decades that followed, Holit faced demographic challenges. By 2010 it had only 25 members, prompting the Settlement Division to consider converting it into a moshav.[9] An effort by settlement institutions and the kibbutz itself to attract and absorb young families helped sustain the community and eventually allowed it to grow again.[9] Among those who chose to make Holit their home was Dr. Hayim Katsman, an American citizen and emerging scholar of Israel Studies who received his Ph.D. in international studies from the University of Washington in 2021; his research focused on Religious-Zionist communities and contemporary trends in Religious Zionism.[10] Katsman won the Association for Israel Studies' 2019 Kimmerling Award for his paper "The Hyphen Cannot Hold: Contemporary Trends in Religious Zionism" and served on Holit's community committee.[10]

Also among Holit's residents were Shachar Deborah and Shlomi Mathias, accomplished musicians who helped found Hagar, a bilingual Arabic-Hebrew school in Beersheba. Their children attended the school, and Shlomi taught music there before the family moved to Holit.[11] Residents of the wider kibbutz area had developed relationships with Palestinian neighbors over many years, including efforts to help Gazans obtain medical care and other assistance.[12]

04Demographics

Before the October 7 attack, Holit had more than 100 residential units and 73 households, with a population reported at approximately 150 to 200 people.[4][9] A 2026 Ynet profile listed about 225 residents even though the community remained evacuated at Kibbutz Revivim and was preparing for a phased return.[13]

Holit is described as a privatized kibbutz—more akin to a community settlement—in which members were responsible for their own income but gathered collectively for holidays and communal celebrations.[4]

05Economy and Culture

Agriculture dominated Holit's economy, accounting for around 97 percent of the kibbutz's income. Field crops, orchards, a citrus grove, a dairy farm, and a factory producing citrus-pressing machines formed the backbone of its livelihoods.[4][9] By the time of a 2025 report, the irrigated greenery that had given Holit its reputation as a desert oasis had largely given way to sand following the disruption of agricultural activity after October 7.[4]

The kibbutz also hosted a Negev pre-military preparatory academy and, before the attack, became a training farm for Hashomer Hatzair immigration groups.[9]

06Notable Sites

A joint energy-storage facility operated with Doral Energy stands outside Holit near a large solar-panel field. CTech described it as the first project in Israel to combine solar energy and battery storage, enabling solar-generated electricity to remain available after sunset during hours of high demand.[14]

Holit's principal communal facilities include its dining hall, dairy farm, cultural buildings, children's spaces, gym, ceramics studio, and community garden. These sites were among the facilities undergoing renewal as residents began returning in 2026.[15]

07The October 7, 2023, Attack

At 6:29 a.m. on October 7, 2023, rockets and infiltration began across the Gaza border region.[6] Missiles and sirens woke Holit's residents shortly afterward.[3] The first terrorists were identified outside the kibbutz at 6:45 a.m.[16] Two IDF patrol vehicles reached the kibbutz gate at 6:56 a.m. but could not enter and departed after roughly twenty minutes for another combat location.[6][2] At 6:59 a.m., attackers blew up the eastern perimeter fence and entered the kibbutz.[1][6]

Only four armed members of the local defense squad were present at the time of the breach, out of an authorized complement of sixteen.[6] Security coordinator Avi Korin moved toward the attackers and confronted them alone; he was killed at 7:10 a.m.[1][6] His deputy, Shimon Azoulay, continued fighting for hours and directed the community's defense in Korin's absence.[2] The first Israeli military reinforcements did not enter the kibbutz until 1:53 p.m., leaving residents and the local squad to bear the main burden of resistance for nearly seven hours.[1][6] The Paran Brigade commander arrived with tanks and counterterrorism forces at 2:06 p.m., which the Mako account of the IDF investigation identified as the turning point of the battle.[6]

Accounts differ on the number of attackers. The Jewish Virtual Library reports approximately 60 Hamas terrorists.[1] Ynet describes four defense-squad members facing approximately 100 Nukhba terrorists attacking in two waves.[2] A Maariv account quotes a resident estimating that roughly 70 Nukhba terrorists entered first, followed by waves of looters.[9] Mako reports only "dozens" without specifying a figure.[6]

The attackers moved from house to house, deliberately targeting civilian residents.[17] Homes were set on fire, people were murdered in their homes, and the Ziyadne family was abducted from a cowshed.[1] In Holit's emergency WhatsApp group, residents sent desperate messages asking for help and reporting gunfire and burning houses.[18] Moshe Ridler, 91 years old, and his Moldovan caregiver, Petru Boscov, were among those murdered.[18]

Adi Vital-Kaploun, 33, called her husband during the attack to ask for instructions on using a rifle kept in a safe; at 12:30 p.m. she shot an attacker who entered her home, then was killed by other attackers in front of her two small children, four-year-old Negev and 15-week-old Eshel.[1][3] Resident Avital Alajem hid with a neighbor in a safe-room closet after attackers reached her home approximately seven hours into the attack.[3] The attackers then forced Alajem and the two children to accompany them toward Gaza; near a settled area inside Gaza, the group was released.[3] Alajem walked back to Israel carrying both children, one of whom had a leg wound.[3] The IDF investigation account renders her surname as Eldajam and describes her returning from Gaza on foot with the two children.[2]

Shir Azoulay heard the sirens at 6:30 a.m. and initially went outside to observe and photograph the rockets; after seeing armed people she identified as Hamas terrorists, she returned to her safe room.[19] When her neighbor Miriam sent a message that her house was on fire and she was choking from smoke, Azoulay left her own burning home to help.[19] She and other neighbors broke through a window and removed its metal shield to reach Miriam, who had lost consciousness in a smoke-filled safe room; they revived her with water and helped her escape.[19] The group was ultimately rescued from the kibbutz after approximately twelve hours.[19]

Ronit Sultan, a mother of two and longtime childhood educator whose parents had immigrated from Argentina, texted her daughter-in-law at 7:56 a.m. to "take care of yourself." Ten minutes later she told a friend that Hamas terrorists were "trying to get in" to her house.[12] Sultan and her husband were killed.[12]

Shachar Deborah and Shlomi Mathias were murdered in the safe room of their home while protecting their son Rotem.[11] Their children Shir, Shakked, and Rotem survived.[11] An inscription on the couple's memorial reads that they "were murdered while defending their home at Kibbutz Holit on October 7, 2023."[11] Dr. Hayim Katsman was murdered in his home while protecting his neighbor.[10]

Armed civilians and the local defense squad killed approximately 20 attackers before military reinforcements arrived.[1] Dr. Hayim Katsman, identified by Mako as a defense-squad member killed in the battle, and counterterrorism fighter Liran Elmosnino were also among the dead.[10][6] Clearing operations continued through the afternoon, and attackers were still being found and killed in surrounding orchards as late as October 9; Avi Korin's body was not recovered until October 12.[1]

08Casualties and Abductions

Casualty figures reported across sources vary depending on which categories of victims each account includes. The U.S. Department of Justice complaint, as of its filing, identified approximately 13 victims from and in Holit as murdered, including at least one American citizen.[17] Mako and the Jewish Virtual Library each report 13 civilians murdered and three security personnel killed.[6][1] Ynet identified 13 kibbutz members murdered and two defense-squad members killed in battle.[2] A JNS report cited 13 people killed in a community of about 200.[18] A separate Times of Israel report from 2024 counted 12 residents and three foreign workers killed.[20] Maariv lists 15 Holit members and residents murdered, plus two people from a neighboring community, a police officer, and two Rahat dairy workers later killed in captivity.[9] The Jewish Virtual Library separately reports that 15 of Holit's 150 residents—one in ten—were killed.[1] These figures use different definitions and reference points and are not reconciled in the reports.

Six residents were abducted to Gaza.[2] In addition, a woman and two children—Avital Alajem and the Vital-Kaploun children—were taken toward Gaza but released the same day.[2] Of the six abducted residents, four were returned in a hostage deal; two were murdered in captivity, and their bodies were returned to Israel.[2] Mako describes the six abducted civilians as four Israelis and two foreign workers.[6]

A Maariv account recounts that Naama Kovani and Gideon sheltered in a safe room for twelve hours before a company medic reached them.[9] The same medic evacuated a wounded boy whose mother had been killed while shielding him from gunfire; the boy was taken to Soroka Hospital in Beersheba.[9]

09IDF Investigation and Military Failure

An IDF investigation led by Colonel Eylon Peretz and approved by former IDF Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Herzi Halevi concluded that the military had failed in its mission to protect Holit and its residents.[6] The investigation found that the eastern fence had been breached at 6:59 a.m. and that patrol vehicles had departed for another battle shortly before the breach.[6] The first effective reinforcement force did not enter the kibbutz until 1:53 p.m., a gap of nearly seven hours.[2][6]

The investigation attributed the delay in effective reinforcement to several factors, including damage to the Nahal Reconnaissance Unit's command system and an incorrect operational picture held by forces from the Caracal and Bardelas battalions.[6] The investigation characterized these battalion commanders' errors as professional failures rather than moral ones.[6] At a broader level, the probe attributed the military's failure primarily to its lack of preparation for a coordinated mass assault on multiple civilian communities and army bases simultaneously.[1]

Despite the military's failure, the investigation praised the actions of Holit's residents and defense squad as a "model of civilian heroism."[6] Holit's community welcomed the investigation as an important step but said it was not the end of the process; the community called for a state commission of inquiry and stated that it expected real security improvements and implementation of lessons before residents would return home.[6] Holit characterized October 7 as a day of extraordinary civilian courage alongside a major military failure.[6]

10Notable Residents

Dr. Hayim Katsman, an American citizen who chose to make Israel his home, was a member of Holit's community committee and an emerging scholar in the field of Israel Studies.[10] He completed his doctorate in international studies at the University of Washington in 2021, with research centered on Religious-Zionist communities, contemporary trends within Religious Zionism, and that movement's relationship to radicalism.[10] His paper "The Hyphen Cannot Hold: Contemporary Trends in Religious Zionism" earned him the Association for Israel Studies' Kimmerling Award in 2019.[10] He was murdered in his home on October 7, 2023, while protecting his neighbor.[10]

Shachar Deborah and Shlomi Mathias were accomplished musicians and community builders who helped found Hagar, a bilingual Arabic-Hebrew school in Beersheba, before moving to Holit.[11] Shlomi taught music at the school, and the couple's children—Shir, Shakked, and Rotem—attended it.[11] Both parents were murdered in their safe room on October 7 while defending Rotem; all three children survived.[11]

Ronit Sultan, a childhood educator whose family had roots in Argentina, and her husband were killed in the attack.[12] Security coordinator Avi Korin, 56, was killed after moving toward the attackers at the outset of the assault.[1] His deputy, Shimon Azoulay, sustained the community's defense for hours after Korin fell.[2]

11Evacuation and Reconstruction

Holit was the first kibbutz to self-evacuate on October 7, 2023.[4] Residents initially relocated to a hotel at Kibbutz Ein Gedi; from there, roughly two-thirds moved to temporary accommodation at Kibbutz Revivim, approximately one-third went to Rehovot, and a small number settled elsewhere.[4]

The attack left every public building in Holit damaged to some degree, and most residential buildings were also affected.[4][1] More than half of the most severely damaged homes had been set on fire, and 14 were demolished entirely.[4] Agricultural activity—which had generated 97 percent of the kibbutz's pre-attack income—came to a halt and was not maintained after the attack.[4][1]

Reconstruction plans included protected public buildings and significant upgrades to residential homes, such as steel entrance doors and gunfire-resistant doors for protected rooms, as well as a new early-education complex with daycare and kindergarten facilities.[4] In December 2024, the Tekuma Directorate approved NIS 57 million for Holit's physical rehabilitation, including extensive renovation of 110 homes.[4][21] A separate one-off government grant of NIS 16 million was allocated for construction and infrastructure.[4] Despite these allocations, the kibbutz remained approximately NIS 10 million short for public buildings and home-security improvements and was actively seeking donors.[4]

Residents noted that fundraising proved difficult because Holit was less well known than other stricken communities, and the kibbutz received less public attention and donor support despite the scale of its losses.[1] Holit began laying foundations for its first ten new homes in November 2025, later than visible reconstruction seen at other kibbutzim such as Be'eri, with further construction slowed by internal disagreements.[1]

A 2026 Ynet report found that seven families had returned to Holit and five new families had joined, with kibbutz leadership expecting approximately half the community to return in August of that year.[15] A CTech report from September 2026 confirmed that the community had formally begun its return process in August and that residents might remain in temporary communities for up to a year after kibbutz rehabilitation was complete.[21]

12Controversies and Contested Accounts

A number of factual details about Holit—including its founding date, the number of attackers on October 7, and total casualties—are reported inconsistently across sources. Ynet and the U.S. Department of Justice place the kibbutz's founding in 1977.[5][2] Maariv states that it began as a Nahal outpost in 1976 and received civilian-community status in 1978, while JNS gives 1978 as the founding year.[9][18] The sources agree that Holit moved to its current location in 1982.[5][2]

Attacker estimates also differ. Ynet reports approximately 100 Nukhba terrorists attacking in two waves.[2] Maariv quotes an estimate of roughly 70 Nukhba terrorists followed by looters.[9] Mako reports only dozens, while the Jewish Virtual Library gives approximately 60.[6][1]

Fatality counts vary with the categories used. Mako lists 13 civilians and three security personnel, while Ynet counts 13 kibbutz members and two defense-squad members.[6][2] Maariv uses a broader list that includes Holit members and residents, helpers from a neighboring community, a police officer, and dairy workers later killed in captivity.[9] The cited reports do not provide a single consistently defined total.

The U.S. Department of Justice account comes from a criminal complaint, so its factual descriptions are allegations rather than adjudicated findings.[17] The conclusion that the military failed to defend Holit is presented as the finding of an attributed IDF investigative process led by Colonel Eylon Peretz and reviewed by the former chief of staff.[6] Holit's community has called for a broader state commission of inquiry, indicating that it does not regard the IDF probe as the final word on accountability.[6]

Sources

  1. 1Jewish Virtual Library, The Israel-Hamas War: The Massacre, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  2. 2Ynetnews, 100 Hamas terrorists, 4 armed civilians and no soldiers: IDF releases Holit Oct. 7 massacre probe, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  3. 3The Jewish Agency for Israel, Keeping Her Neighbor’s Children Alive, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  4. 4The Times of Israel, Desert Oasis, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  5. 5U.S. Department of Justice, U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  6. 6Mako, "A Model of Civilian Heroism": Findings of the Battle Investigation at Kibbutz Holit on October 7, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  7. 7Institute for National Security Studies, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  8. 8Jewish Virtual Library, Yammit Region, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  9. 9Maariv, "Not So Many People Heard About It Because We Are a Small Kibbutz, But the Blow to Us Was Devastating and Very Painful", accessed on October 15, 2026.
  10. 10Association for Israel Studies, Hayim Katsman, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  11. 11Sapir, Mourning and Memorialization | SAPIR Journal, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  12. 12Foundation for Defense of Democracies, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  13. 13Ynet, 100 Nukhba Terrorists Against 4 Defense-Squad Members — and Not a Single Fighter: An Investigation into the Massacre at Holit and Its Failures, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  14. 14CTech by Calcalist, Spark of genius: Kibbutzim's quest for profit and planet-saving sustainability, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  15. 15Ynetnews, ‘I survived, I returned home’: The residents returning to Kibbutz Holit after Oct. 7, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  16. 16The Times of Israel, IDF Probe, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  17. 17U.S. Department of Justice, sealed complaint, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  18. 18Jewish News Syndicate, Survived the Holocaust, killed by Hamas, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  19. 19The Jewish Agency for Israel, Saved her neighbor from Hamas-Set House Fire, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  20. 20The Times of Israel, Rebuild, accessed on October 15, 2026.
  21. 21CTech by Calcalist, Four Gaza border kibbutzim are finally heading home, but the hardest part may come next, accessed on October 15, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What is Holit?

    Holit is a kibbutz in the Eshkol Regional Council in southern Israel, located near the southern Gaza Strip and the Gaza–Egypt border area. It is a small agricultural community that was known as a desert oasis landscaped with irrigated greenery in an otherwise arid region. The kibbutz was originally founded in the Yamit region of the Sinai Peninsula in the mid-to-late 1970s and relocated to its current site in 1982 following Israel's withdrawal from Sinai under the Camp David Accords.

  • How did Holit come to be located in the Negev near Gaza?

    Holit's origins lie in the Yamit region of the northeastern Sinai Peninsula, where Israel established settlements following the 1967 war. Following the Camp David Accords and Israel's peace agreement with Egypt, Israel evacuated its Sinai settlements, and Holit was relocated to its current position in the southern Negev near the Gaza border in 1982.

  • What happened at Holit during the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack?

    On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists breached Holit's eastern perimeter fence at 6:59 a.m. and invaded the kibbutz, moving from house to house and deliberately targeting civilians. At least thirteen civilians were murdered, homes were set ablaze, and six residents were abducted to Gaza. Only four armed members of the local defense squad were present at the time of the breach, and the first Israeli military reinforcements did not enter the kibbutz until 1:53 p.m., leaving residents to bear the main burden of resistance for nearly seven hours.

  • What did the IDF investigation into the October 7 attack on Holit conclude?

    An IDF investigation led by Colonel Eylon Peretz and approved by former IDF Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Herzi Halevi concluded that the military had failed in its mission to protect Holit and its residents. The investigation attributed the failure primarily to the military's lack of preparation for a coordinated mass assault on multiple civilian communities and army bases simultaneously. Despite this failure, the investigation praised the actions of Holit's residents and defense squad as a "model of civilian heroism."

  • What was Holit's economy based on before the October 7 attack?

    Agriculture dominated Holit's economy, accounting for around 97 percent of the kibbutz's income. Field crops, orchards, a citrus grove, a dairy farm, and a factory producing citrus-pressing machines formed the backbone of its livelihoods. Agricultural activity came to a halt after October 7 and was not maintained following the attack.

  • What is notable about the energy facility near Holit?

    A joint energy-storage facility operated with Doral Energy stands outside Holit near a large solar-panel field. CTech described it as the first project in Israel to combine solar energy and battery storage, enabling solar-generated electricity to remain available after sunset during hours of high demand.

  • What is the status of Holit's reconstruction and return of residents?

    Holit was the first kibbutz to self-evacuate on October 7, 2023, with residents relocating primarily to Kibbutz Revivim and other temporary accommodations. In December 2024, the Tekuma Directorate approved NIS 57 million for physical rehabilitation, including renovation of 110 homes, though the kibbutz remained approximately NIS 10 million short for public buildings and home-security improvements. Holit began laying foundations for its first ten new homes in November 2025, and a 2026 report found that seven families had returned with five new families joining, with leadership expecting approximately half the community to return in August of that year.