← All articles

Total current articles · 4,848

Freedom Flotilla II

Published

01In brief

The Freedom Flotilla II was an international maritime campaign organized in 2011 to sail to Gaza and challenge Israel’s naval blockade, following the May 2010 flotilla. At a June 27 press conference in Athens, organizers projected ten ships carrying 327 passengers, including 37 media personnel, and about 3,000 tons of supplies. Greek departure restrictions, technical problems, and withdrawals prevented the planned fleet from sailing together; the French yacht Dignité Al-Karama ultimately approached Gaza alone and was intercepted by the Israeli Navy on July 19 without resistance.

02Background

The campaign was conceived as a follow-up to the May 2010 Gaza flotilla and was also called “Freedom Fleet 2” and “Freedom Flotilla II – Stay Human.”[1][5] Its organizing network included the Cyprus-based Free Gaza Movement and European organizations; after the Turkish organization IHH withdrew, principal organizers included the Free Gaza Movement, the European Campaign to End the Siege on Gaza, and U.S. Boat to Gaza.[6][7]

The preceding flotilla remained central to preparations: the new voyage was organized around the first anniversary of the May 31, 2010 confrontation.[8] In June 2011, IHH published a book titled “Freedom Flotilla through Language of Global Conscience: Interviews with Passengers,” containing testimony from 39 passengers on the earlier voyage, including Sheikh Raed Salah.[9]

Organizers described the proposed voyage as both an aid effort and a campaign to change Israeli policy.[10] In May, IHH spokesman Ömer Faruk said it would proceed despite the planned opening of the Rafah crossing, emphasizing its intended role in drawing attention to Palestinian suffering; Free Gaza Movement activist Huwaida Arraf likewise described changing Israeli policy as its purpose.[10] In June, organizer Adam Shapiro said aid was secondary to challenging Israeli policy and raising awareness of Palestinian freedom and what he called the continuing occupation in Gaza.[11]

The United States opposed attempts to break the maritime blockade and urged aid providers to use established delivery channels, including Ashdod, where cargo could be unloaded, inspected, and transported to Gaza.[8] Its June statement connected cargo screening to recent Israeli and Egyptian seizures of weapons and military systems bound for Gaza, as well as rocket and mortar attacks against Israeli civilians.[8] It also acknowledged continuing concern about conditions in Gaza while describing improvements over the preceding year, including a wider range of incoming goods, increased international project activity, and gradually expanding exports.[8]

03Course of Events

In March 2011, organizers announced a projected fleet of 15 ships carrying humanitarian aid and close to 1,000 passengers, with a departure anticipated for mid-May.[1] Subsequent planning envisaged as many as 1,500 activists from 100 countries aboard 15 vessels, including two large passenger ships, with sailing shifted to the third week of June from several European ports, including Marseille.[7] These figures represented successive proposals rather than confirmed numbers of ships or passengers that sailed.[1][7]

Preparations extended across several countries: a Swiss-German ship was expected to join, while Australian organizers announced that a vessel named Tahrir would carry 50 Australian passengers and some Canadians.[12] Organizers also planned meetings with European officials and representatives of the United Nations and other international organizations to seek support.[12] Ships from the United States, Canada, Greece, Ireland, France, and Italy were announced, and journalists and politicians were invited to participate.[5] Dror Feiler called for UN and European Union representatives to inspect passengers and cargo before and after the voyage and said journalists and dozens of European parliamentarians were expected to join.[10]

By June 15, Shapiro said ten ships and around 300 activists from dozens of countries were expected, rejecting reports that as many as 25 ships would sail.[11] The plan was to assemble in international waters in the eastern Mediterranean before proceeding toward Gaza, although a departure date had not been settled.[11] Shapiro said Turkish participation was desired but that the campaign would continue if IHH postponed its involvement.[11]

IHH subsequently withdrew, citing unfinished repairs to the Mavi Marmara.[13] In remarks entered in the Congressional Record on June 24, Representative Steve Israel stated that IHH had announced its withdrawal earlier that month and that other participants intended to proceed.[14] Representative Steve Israel also said that 34 members of Congress had joined him and Representative Tom Cole in writing to Turkey’s prime minister to urge the government to discourage the flotilla.[14]

Legal and administrative pressure affected preparations before the planned departure.[11][13] Shurat HaDin sent letters to maritime insurers, filed a complaint concerning satellite communications provider Inmarsat, and contacted Greek officials about detaining ships.[13] One French boat expected to participate was canceled after its prospective insurer withdrew following a legal warning from Shurat HaDin, which claimed credit for that cancellation.[11] Cyprus also prohibited Gaza-bound sailings from its seaports.[5]

At the June 27 Athens press conference, organizers announced ten ships, including two cargo vessels, and projected 327 passengers, among them 37 media personnel.[2] They said the ships would carry approximately 3,000 tons of supplies, including medicine and concrete, meet in international waters, and then head to Gaza with a message of peace.[2] Preparations in Gaza included a Hamas-run exercise simulating boats meeting the flotilla at sea, escorting it into territorial waters, evacuating wounded people, and a confrontation with the Israeli Navy.[15]

A June 28 internal planning memorandum projected a smaller contingent than early announcements: its most optimistic estimate was 292 passengers and 36 journalists.[16] Expected allocations included 65 people on the Italian Stefano Chiarini, 48 on the Canadian Tahrir, and 40 on the American Audacity of Hope.[16] Seven additional ships from Spain, Ireland, Sweden, Greece, and Norway were expected, but the projections depended on vessels being declared fit and receiving Greek departure authorization.[16] The Audacity of Hope was already being held in port.[16]

Other reporting shortly before departure described six participating ships detained by Greek port authorities and estimated that no more than seven ships carrying 200–500 passengers would ultimately participate, despite organizers’ continuing claims of more than 1,500 prospective activists.[17] Technical problems also delayed vessels, including the Greek-Swedish Juliano and the Irish Saoirse; organizers said repairs were possible and that the American vessel was ready to sail.[2]

On July 1, Greece prohibited ships under Greek or foreign flags from leaving its ports for Gaza and directed the Hellenic Coast Guard to enforce the restriction.[18] Greek authorities cited security concerns following the previous year’s confrontation aboard a Turkish vessel, in which nine activists had died.[19] The restrictions prevented the planned fleet from departing together.[4]

Organizers rejected an offer to have Greek Navy ships deliver their humanitarian aid.[20] On July 4, Free Gaza Movement leader Ewa Jasiewicz said such delivery would not constitute breaking the siege and that participants would continue looking for ways to sail despite the Greek order.[20] Israel’s Foreign Ministry spokesman considered delivery under UN supervision reasonable if the cargo was checked for weapons, while Hamas called on Greece to reverse its decision.[20]

Several vessels attempted to leave despite the restrictions.[19] John Klusmire, captain of the Audacity of Hope, was arrested after trying to depart without permission and was released by a Greek court on July 5.[19] He faced charges of endangering passengers’ lives and leaving port without authorization, and the ship was impounded.[13] The Tahrir attempted to leave Crete but was forced back by Coast Guard vessels; three activists were detained, one for sailing without permission and two for using kayaks to obstruct a Coast Guard vessel.[19]

The Juliano, named for actor Juliano Mer-Khamis, underwent repairs and attempted to sail on July 5, but was stopped and taken to a Greek port.[16][21] By July 9 it was at Heraklion on Crete, where passengers were presented with a document stating that Sierra Leone had canceled the vessel’s registration.[21]

The French-flagged Dignité Al-Karama eventually left Kastellorizo on July 16, officially bound for Alexandria.[22] It carried 16 people: ten activists, three journalists, and three crew members.[7] Most were French nationals, and the journalists included Haaretz columnist Amira Hass; three passengers represented boats blocked from leaving Greece.[23] It was the only vessel from the planned flotilla to reach the area of the Gaza naval blockade.[7]

On July 19, the Israeli Navy intercepted the yacht at approximately 10:30 a.m., about 12 nautical miles from Gaza, and directed it to divert to Ashdod or Egypt.[3] After it refused, Chief of Staff Benny Gantz authorized boarding, and those aboard surrendered without resistance.[3] The passengers were transferred to a naval ship and given food, water, and a medical check; the yacht was taken to Ashdod.[3][22]

During a radio exchange, the captain identified Gaza port as the destination and, when asked about cargo, replied, “We have no cargo, we are a private pleasure boat.”[24] Israeli naval personnel warned that the route led into the naval blockade area and offered land crossings as an alternative route for reaching Gaza.[24]

04Aftermath

By July 8, about 300 activists, mostly from North America and Europe, had spent nearly two weeks in Greece, and organizers had decided to send most of them home.[4] Arraf explained: “We had planned on launching Freedom Flotilla 2 with a certain time frame and weren't able to do it within the time frame, so a lot of people are going home and we are strategizing and planning.”[4]

A subsequent update described most participants as having returned home after three weeks in Greece, although organizers continued to express an intention to send one ship.[21] The U.S. network announced that its participation had ended and its activists were returning home, while the Canadian delegation also canceled its participation.[21] The July 19 interception of Dignité Al-Karama left the proposed ten-ship voyage unrealized.[7]

The episode prompted a legislative response in the United States: H.R. 3131 was introduced in the House of Representatives on October 6, 2011.[18] It proposed expressing congressional thanks to Greece for preventing the flotilla from sailing and requiring a State Department report on whether organizations supporting the attempt should be designated foreign terrorist organizations.[25] The bill was referred to a House subcommittee on October 25 and did not become law; its proposed reporting requirement did not itself designate any organization.[25]

05Historiography and Disputed Claims

Organizers’ allegations of Israeli sabotage became a prominent dispute during the preparations.[2][16] They attributed damage to the Juliano and Saoirse to Israel, and Feiler said repairs to the Juliano would take several days; the available accounts report those accusations without independently establishing responsibility.[2][16]

Claims about possible violence were also disputed: Feiler denied allegations that activists intended to attack Israeli soldiers with chemical substances or set them on fire, calling the claims false and denying violent intentions.[16] The interception of Dignité Al-Karama itself occurred without resistance.[3]

The yacht’s destination generated conflicting accounts: it had declared Egypt as its destination, while its captain later identified Gaza port in a radio exchange.[3][24] Israeli military sources relayed the captain’s claim that passengers had at times taken control and changed course, but questioned whether he was seeking to avoid responsibility.[3] These reported statements do not independently resolve who determined the course changes.[3]

Political and legal characterizations likewise require distinction from the sequence of events: the introduced H.R. 3131 described Israel’s blockade as “legal” and the organizers’ conduct as provocative, but those were the positions expressed in a proposed bill, not an enacted legal determination.[18][25] Organizers’ own statements combined humanitarian aims with an explicit campaign to challenge Israeli policy, rather than presenting aid delivery as the voyage’s sole purpose.[11][20]

Sources

  1. 1Ynetnews, 'Freedom Fleet 2' flotilla to sail to Gaza Strip in May, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  2. 2Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  3. 3Ynetnews, Navy stops French flotilla ship, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  4. 4The Investigative Project on Terrorism, Flotilla Fizzles, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  5. 5Jewish Virtual Library, Myths & Facts: Online Exclusives Archive, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  6. 6Anti-Defamation League, Free Gaza Movement, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  7. 7Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  8. 8U.S. Department of State, Gaza "Anniversary" Flotilla, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  9. 9Ynet, IHH publishes 2nd Marmara book, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  10. 10Ynet, Flotilla to go ahead despite open crossing, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  11. 11The Jerusalem Post, Organizer says flotilla to sail even if IHH cancels, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  12. 12Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  13. 13NGO Monitor, How to stop a flotilla, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  14. 14Congress.gov, Congressional Record, Steve Israel, “Planned Flotilla to Gaza, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  15. 15Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  16. 16Ynetnews, Fewer than 300 join flotilla, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  17. 17Ynetnews, Gaza flotilla losing momentum, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  18. 18Congress.gov, H.R. 3131, introduced text, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  19. 19Ynetnews, Pro-Palestinian activists occupy embassy in Athens, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  20. 20The Jerusalem Post, Activists reject Greek offer to send flotilla aid, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  21. 21Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  22. 22Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  23. 23Ynetnews, French flotilla boat en route to Gaza, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  24. 24Globes, The Gaza flotilla: The Navy took control of the ship without resistance, accessed on November 4, 2026.
  25. 25Congress.gov, H.R. 3131 bill page, accessed on November 4, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What was Freedom Flotilla II?

    Freedom Flotilla II was an international maritime campaign organized in 2011 to sail to Gaza and challenge Israel’s naval blockade. Organizers planned a fleet carrying activists and supplies, following the May 2010 flotilla. Greek departure restrictions, technical problems, and withdrawals prevented the planned fleet from sailing together; only the French yacht Dignité Al-Karama reached the area of the Gaza naval blockade.

  • Why did organizers launch Freedom Flotilla II?

    Organizers described Freedom Flotilla II as both an aid effort and a campaign to change Israeli policy and raise awareness of Palestinian freedom and conditions in Gaza. Some organizers said aid was secondary to challenging Israeli policy. The campaign was conceived as a follow-up to the May 2010 Gaza flotilla and was organized around the first anniversary of the May 31, 2010 confrontation.

  • How many ships and passengers were planned for Freedom Flotilla II?

    At a June 27, 2011, press conference in Athens, organizers announced ten ships and projected 327 passengers, including 37 media personnel. They said the ships would carry approximately 3,000 tons of supplies, including medicine and concrete. Earlier plans had proposed more ships and passengers, but these were successive projections rather than confirmed totals.

  • Why did the Freedom Flotilla II ships fail to sail from Greece?

    Greek restrictions, technical problems, and withdrawals prevented the planned fleet from departing together. On July 1, Greece prohibited ships from leaving its ports for Gaza and directed the Hellenic Coast Guard to enforce the order, citing security concerns. Several vessels were also delayed or detained, and some participants and delegations withdrew.

  • What happened to Dignité Al-Karama during Freedom Flotilla II?

    Dignité Al-Karama was the only vessel from the planned flotilla to reach the area of the Gaza naval blockade. The French-flagged yacht left Kastellorizo on July 16, 2011, carrying 16 people, and was intercepted by the Israeli Navy on July 19 about 12 nautical miles from Gaza. Those aboard surrendered without resistance, and the yacht was taken to Ashdod.

  • What happened after the Freedom Flotilla II attempt?

    Most of the activists who had waited in Greece returned home, and the U.S. network and Canadian delegation ended their participation. In the United States, H.R. 3131 was introduced in the House of Representatives on October 6, 2011. The bill proposed thanking Greece for preventing the flotilla from sailing and requiring a State Department report, but it did not become law.