← All articles

Total current articles · 5,097

Congregation B'nai Israel (Auburn, New York)

Published

01In brief

Congregation B'nai Israel was a Jewish congregation in Auburn, New York, formally organized in 1903 and associated with synagogues on Seminary Avenue and John Smith Avenue. Its replacement synagogue, dedicated in 1974, was an 8,000-square-foot building with a large wood-and-glass Star of David embedded in the second-floor ceiling. Originally Orthodox, the congregation became Conservative in 1935 and maintained worship and religious education through decades of changing membership before holding its final service in 2013.

02Overview

B’nai Israel served both Auburn’s Jewish residents and holiday worshipers from Geneva, Seneca Falls, and surrounding communities.[1] Its premises accommodated religious services, Hebrew and Sunday school classes, and, at its first permanent property, a residence for the rabbi.[1] The congregation grew to approximately 110 member families during the 1950s, but declining membership eventually limited its ability to support rabbinic leadership and maintain its building.[1]

After its closure, the congregation’s Torah scrolls, stained-glass windows, and remaining financial assets were distributed to religious, cultural, educational, and charitable recipients.[1] As of 2023, its former John Smith Avenue synagogue housed United With Christ Church.[1]

03History

Twenty-six founders formally organized B’nai Israel in 1903, including its first president, Moses Saperstein, as well as Louis Bernson, Israel Goldman, and Isaac Liberman.[1] The congregation initially met in rented spaces before purchasing a house at 18 Seminary Avenue from Annette Hall for $3,500 in 1911.[1] The house accommodated worship, Hebrew school classes, and the rabbi’s residence, but holiday attendance sometimes required larger rented premises, including the auditorium annex of Woodmen’s Hall.[1]

Rabbi Simon Levine, an immigrant from Minsk, led the congregation while supplementing his income as a cattle dealer.[1] In 1915, B’nai Israel hired Charles Tomares as its first full-time rabbi; he left in 1918 for a position in Hartford, Connecticut.[1]

Plans for a permanent synagogue began in 1913, were delayed during World War I, and resumed in 1919.[1] By October 1920, 50 Jewish residents had pledged $5,325 toward construction, with another $10,000 still needed.[1] The Ladies’ Auxiliary raised $1,000 during 1920, and non-Jewish Auburn residents also contributed.[1] Congregants donated furnishings and memorial windows, including a ner tamid from Bella and Solomon Wetzler and a candelabra from Alexander and Celia Levy.[1]

The Seminary Avenue synagogue was dedicated on April 9, 1922, before approximately 175–200 attendees.[1] Those present included Auburn Mayor A. Percival Burkhart, Judge Edgar Mosher, and visitors from nearby communities.[1] The original house on the property was moved to 17 Franklin Street.[1]

By 1935, membership had declined enough that closure had been considered.[1] Under Samuel Schwartz’s leadership that year, B’nai Israel affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and changed from Orthodox to Conservative Judaism.[1] Eleazer Levi became its first Conservative rabbi, followed by several rabbis whose individual tenures lasted less than two years.[1]

By 1969, the congregation was discussing relocation because many Jewish residents lived in eastern Auburn, the Seminary Avenue building had aging infrastructure and accessibility difficulties, and the state planned to demolish the area for a highway.[1] In early 1973, B’nai Israel sold its synagogue to the New York State Department of Transportation.[1] A committee selected 8 John Smith Avenue for the replacement, partly because of its proximity to Jewish families on the city’s eastern side.[1] Most religious articles, furnishings, and stained glass were transferred to the new building, which was dedicated on March 29–30, 1974.[1]

In 1979, while continuing to identify as Conservative, the congregation expanded its rabbinic search to include Reform rabbis.[1] By 1980, it could no longer support a full-time rabbi and arranged periodic visits by student rabbis from the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York City.[1] Rabbi Charles Dobrusin, a part-time rabbi based in Chicago, began serving in 1999, traveling to Auburn monthly for Shabbat services and officiating on major holidays.[1] He remained until 2012, marking the congregation’s final period of rabbinic leadership.[1]

A 2004 flood severely damaged the lower level of the John Smith Avenue building.[1] Although the congregation repaired the damage, maintaining the synagogue became increasingly difficult with a shrinking and aging membership.[1] After membership fell below a minyan, congregational leaders planned for closure, and B’nai Israel held its final service in 2013.[1]

04Demographics

B’nai Israel had 40 affiliated families in 1935, down from a possible peak of 70 households during the 1920s.[1] Membership subsequently rose to approximately 110 families during the 1950s, when Auburn’s Jewish population reached its peak.[1] Estimates placed the city’s Jewish population at 250 residents in both 1918 and 1960.[1]

Membership declined from 90 families in 1969 to approximately 75 at the dedication of the replacement synagogue in 1974 and 60 in 1979.[1] By 1990, when a local reporter described B’nai Israel as “struggling to survive,” an estimated 50–55 Jewish families remained in the Auburn area.[1] In 2005, the congregation had approximately 25 member families, most of them older and without children living at home.[1]

05Economy & Culture

The congregation’s Sunday School reached its highest enrollment of 55 children in 1953, when its Sisterhood had 89 members.[1] B’nai Israel added Sunday School classrooms and, in 1963, dedicated the Annie Abuza Aronson Center at 20 Seminary Avenue.[1] Named for a community leader and philanthropist, the center was funded by her husband, Julius Aronson, and other donors and contained religious-school classrooms and a study for the rabbi.[1]

The religious school had ten students in 1990 and eight by 2004.[1] Lay leaders and education director Elaine Cohen helped sustain religious life as the congregation contracted.[1] Cohen continued religious instruction in Cayuga County until the synagogue closed.[1]

Following closure, the congregation’s three Torah scrolls went to Temple Kol Tikvah in Davidson, North Carolina; 6 Points Sci-Tech Academy in Massachusetts; and Israel, where one became part of the Eisendrath International Exchange Semester program.[1] Its remaining assets were entrusted to the Jewish Federation of Central New York to support Holocaust education, Jewish summer camp scholarships, and Kosher Meals on Wheels through Syracuse Jewish Family Service.[1]

06Notable Sites

The Seminary Avenue synagogue, dedicated in 1922, remained in use through the transition to the John Smith Avenue building, which was dedicated in 1974.[1] The John Smith Avenue synagogue was designed by local architect John Critchley and built by Sabotka Construction Company.[1] The two-level, 8,000-square-foot structure contained classrooms, offices, and a small chapel on its lower level, with the main sanctuary and a social hall upstairs.[1] A large Star of David made of wood and glass was embedded in the second-floor ceiling.[1]

The congregation preserved religious furnishings and stained glass from its Seminary Avenue synagogue when it moved to John Smith Avenue.[1] After the congregation closed, its historic stained-glass windows were donated to the Cayuga Museum.[1] The John Smith Avenue property was sold to a Christian congregation and, as of 2023, housed United With Christ Church.[1]

Sources

  1. 1Jewish Virtual Library, A History of Jewish Life in Auburn, New York and Surrounding Areas, accessed on November 19, 2026.

IsraelPedia Question & Answers

  • What was Congregation B'nai Israel in Auburn, New York?

    Congregation B'nai Israel was a Jewish congregation in Auburn, New York, formally organized in 1903. Originally Orthodox, it became Conservative in 1935 and maintained worship and religious education through changing membership. The congregation held its final service in 2013.

  • Why did Congregation B'nai Israel move from Seminary Avenue to John Smith Avenue?

    Congregation B'nai Israel moved because many Jewish residents lived in eastern Auburn, its Seminary Avenue building had aging infrastructure and accessibility difficulties, and the state planned to demolish the area for a highway. The congregation sold the Seminary Avenue synagogue in early 1973 and dedicated its replacement at 8 John Smith Avenue on March 29–30, 1974.

  • What was notable about Congregation B'nai Israel's John Smith Avenue synagogue?

    Congregation B'nai Israel's John Smith Avenue synagogue was an 8,000-square-foot, two-level building designed by local architect John Critchley and built by Sabotka Construction Company. It included classrooms, offices, a small chapel, a main sanctuary, and a social hall. A large wood-and-glass Star of David was embedded in the second-floor ceiling.

  • How did Congregation B'nai Israel's membership change over time?

    Congregation B'nai Israel had 40 affiliated families in 1935 and approximately 110 families during the 1950s. Membership fell to 90 families in 1969, approximately 75 in 1974, and 60 in 1979. By 2005, the congregation had approximately 25 member families, most older and without children living at home.

  • What happened to Congregation B'nai Israel's Torah scrolls and other assets after it closed?

    After Congregation B'nai Israel closed, its three Torah scrolls went to Temple Kol Tikvah in Davidson, North Carolina; 6 Points Sci-Tech Academy in Massachusetts; and Israel, where one became part of the Eisendrath International Exchange Semester program. Its remaining assets were entrusted to the Jewish Federation of Central New York for Holocaust education, Jewish summer camp scholarships, and Kosher Meals on Wheels through Syracuse Jewish Family Service.

  • What happened to Congregation B'nai Israel's stained-glass windows and former synagogue?

    Congregation B'nai Israel's historic stained-glass windows were donated to the Cayuga Museum after the congregation closed. The John Smith Avenue property was sold to a Christian congregation and, as of 2023, housed United With Christ Church.