01In brief
The Cherbourg Project was an Israeli naval operation in December 1969 to bring five French-built vessels to Israel after a French arms embargo blocked their delivery. The boats left Cherbourg over Christmas and reached Haifa’s Kishon port on December 31; French authorities discovered their departure on December 26. Organized through a fictitious commercial transaction and supported by merchant ships along the route, the operation recovered the remaining vessels of a twelve-boat order intended for conversion into missile boats. Their departure caused a diplomatic crisis with France, while the vessels subsequently formed part of the Israeli missile-boat force that fought in the 1973 Yom Kippur War.
02Background
The Israeli Navy’s search for small, heavily armed vessels began with the problem of maintaining an effective fighting force on a limited budget while operating a fleet largely inherited from the World War II era.[3] At a two-day brainstorming session convened by naval commander Yohai Bin-Nun in the early 1960s, one proposal was to adapt an Israeli artillery missile for use aboard inexpensive patrol boats.[3] This would give relatively small vessels striking power otherwise associated with much larger warships.[3]
Israeli officers examined designs in European and American navies before selecting a fast, sturdy German patrol-boat design.[3] Germany provided funding for twelve vessels, based on a modified version of its Jaguar torpedo boat, to be built at Cherbourg.[4] Israel turned to the French shipyard after a German construction plan was canceled.[5] In the mid-1960s, Israeli naval engineers worked with the French company Felix Amiot on the Sa’ar 3 boats.[1]
The vessels were intended to reach Israel before undergoing their complex conversion into missile boats.[3] Development involved both the Gabriel sea-to-sea missile and electronic countermeasures against the longer-range Soviet Styx missiles supplied to Egypt and Syria.[3][6] The broader missile-boat development effort carried the codename Shalechet, or “Falling Leaves.”[4] The wider program drew on several countries: the boats and radar were built in France, propulsion and submarine-detection systems came from Germany, and fire-control radar and components for missile seekers and electronic warfare came from Italy.[4] The electronic control center came from the Netherlands, while Israel developed the weapons system and radio equipment.[4]
The threat posed by missile-armed adversaries became particularly stark on October 21, 1967, when Egyptian missile fire sank the Israeli destroyer INS Eilat, killing 47 Israeli sailors and wounding dozens.[5] The loss exposed the vulnerability of Israel’s existing naval forces as missile warfare developed.[5]
03The French Embargo
France had been Israel’s principal supplier of military equipment, including Mirage fighters, during a period of close relations that initially continued under Charles de Gaulle.[1] Those relations deteriorated around the Six-Day War and the subsequent restrictions on arms deliveries.[1][7] An initial embargo preceded the war, and the restrictions became comprehensive in January 1969 after Israel’s raid on Beirut airport.[7] The airport raid followed an attack on an El Al aircraft in Athens in December 1968.[5]
On January 6, 1969, de Gaulle embargoed delivery of military equipment to Israel, affecting five gunboats under preparation at Cherbourg.[2] Seven of the twelve vessels had already reached Israel, leaving the final five subject to the restriction.[3] Construction and sea trials nevertheless continued.[2] The shipbuilder was due to receive final payment when all the vessels were completed.[6] Israel allowed the work to proceed in the hope that the embargo would be lifted before the last boats were ready.[6]
Mordecai “Mocca” Limon, a former Israeli Navy commander heading Israel’s military purchasing mission in Paris, took charge of efforts to secure the remaining vessels.[5] Prime Minister Golda Meir initially opposed simply taking them because she feared France might sever diplomatic relations.[5] She accepted an operation based on a transaction intended to make the boats’ release legally defensible rather than an overt seizure.[5]
04The Commercial Cover
The operation relied on presenting the boats’ departure as a commercial transfer to a third party rather than a delivery to Israel.[5] The Mossad established a front shipping company to buy the vessels, while Israeli teams continued working in the French shipyards.[1] Limon also obtained secret assistance from some mid-level French officials.[3]
Norwegian shipping executive and shipyard owner Martin Siem acted as the apparent purchaser, with the boats presented as suitable for offshore oil-rig support.[5] The arrangement used STARBOAT S.A., a Panamanian company associated with Siem, and a supposed onward sale to a Norwegian company engaged in offshore oil exploration.[5] The purpose was to obtain French authorization for release without openly violating the embargo.[5]
The paperwork included documents waiving Israel’s claim and transferring the boats from the Cherbourg shipyard to Siem’s company.[6] The following day, Limon, Siem, and shipyard owner Felix Amiot signed a second set of documents reversing that transaction and restoring the earlier arrangement.[6] These second documents were not submitted to the French authorities, leaving officials with papers that appeared to resolve the blocked sale while the underlying arrangement kept the vessels in Israeli hands.[6]
The sale contract was completed on December 22, 1969, and French customs signed release papers two days later, with Norway listed as the boats’ nominal destination.[5] Meir’s approval depended on the deception persuading the French authorities to authorize release; a commando-style seizure had also been proposed during planning.[5]
05Crews and Voyage Preparations
Nearly 100 Israeli naval crewmen, most of them young conscripts, traveled to France in civilian clothes and were concealed aboard the boats at Cherbourg.[6] They arrived in small groups, traveling through Paris and continuing to Cherbourg by train before joining the skeleton crews already aboard.[3] Approximately 120 people were involved in the preparations.[5]
Supply officers purchased food in small quantities from local shops, and fuel was loaded incrementally to avoid drawing attention.[6] Provisions were spread across purchases at multiple supermarkets.[5] Because some boats lacked radios, operation commander Hadar Kimche bought children’s walkie-talkies from toy shops and arranged for the vessels to remain close together, with an agreed mast-light signal available for communication.[5]
Israeli merchant ships were positioned along the route to provide fuel, rescue support, and other assistance.[3][5] Their crews trained to refuel the small vessels at sea, and radio arrangements were established before departure.[5] Zim supplied two merchant ships to act as tankers under the cover of an assignment to unload phosphates at Rouen.[5]
Launching the vessels also required attention to the water level at the shipyard’s sloping railway ramp.[5] A boat needed water 4.80 meters above the lower level to float free of its cradle, making the launch dependent on a suitable tidal window.[5] Christmas was chosen for departure partly because harbor security was expected to be less alert during the holiday.[3]
06Departure and Passage to Haifa
A severe gale in the English Channel delayed the planned Christmas departure.[3] After a BBC weather bulletin indicated a favorable change in the wind, Kimche ordered the five boats to leave in the early hours, and they sailed from Cherbourg in single file as Limon watched from the pier.[3] The completed vessels departed during the Christmas period, before French authorities discovered their absence on December 26.[2]
The boats encountered heavy seas in the English Channel and Bay of Biscay.[8] Kimche ordered crew members to remain below deck unless secured by a line, and some bridge officers lashed themselves to their seats.[8] He adjusted the lead vessel’s speed to cope with the waves while crews endured widespread seasickness.[8] The boats temporarily lost contact with one another but regrouped off Portugal.[3]
Gadi Ben Ze’ev, commander of INS Hanit during the operation, later recalled that men tied themselves to the vessel to avoid being thrown about.[5] He described losing five kilograms through exertion, hunger, and fatigue during the passage.[5] Merchant vessels met the boats along the route to provide fuel and assistance.[3][5]
A local journalist noticed the vessels’ absence two days after their departure, with the Christmas holiday contributing to the delay in discovery.[3] Once the operation became public, false leads planted by Limon suggested destinations including Norway, Alaska, and Panama, while news crews searched for the missing boats.[3] France’s defense minister urged interception, but Georges Pompidou did not pursue that course.[3]
As the vessels passed Gibraltar, a British naval post signaled “What ship?” and, after receiving no answer from Kimche, sent “bon voyage.”[3] The boats later met refueling vessels in secluded coves, and Israeli Phantom jets flew low over them near Crete in welcome.[3] They reached Haifa’s Kishon port on December 31, 1969, where harbor sirens and crowds greeted their arrival.[1]
07Aftermath
The boats’ departure produced a diplomatic crisis between France and Israel.[7] A French investigation concluded that Israel had purchased the ships through an intermediary; two senior French officials were suspended, and Israel’s senior military representative was required to leave France.[2] Limon was required to leave France, although accounts differ over whether the measure was an expulsion or a demand for his recall.[6][7]
The French government reacted angrily when it became clear that the boats were heading to Israel.[5] Much of the French public and media responded more favorably, viewing the embargo as a political measure rather than a response to harm Israel had caused France.[6] The wider diplomatic falling-out contributed to Israel’s turn toward the United States as an ally and military supplier.[1]
Recovering the five boats did not immediately create an operational missile flotilla.[6] The Cherbourg vessels were delivered unarmed and fitted in Israel with Israeli-designed and manufactured Gabriel missiles.[9] Conversion, tactical development, and crew training required nearly four more years.[6] All twelve vessels were fitted out as missile boats, while the Navy developed the operational systems and tactics needed to use them.[3]
09Historical Interpretation
The operation’s legal character rests on the distinction between Israel’s prior purchase of the boats and the concealed transaction used to obtain their release under the embargo.[3][5] Descriptions of the episode as a theft therefore coexist with accounts emphasizing Israel’s ownership and the French authorization secured through the commercial cover.[3][5] The undisclosed documents reversing the apparent sale are central to understanding why the departure was neither an ordinary delivery nor an openly declared transfer to Israel.[6]
Accounts also differ in their description of the diplomatic sanction against Limon: some describe an expulsion, while another distinguishes a demand for his recall from a formal declaration of persona non grata.[6][7] These differences do not alter the central outcome: the five boats reached Israel, and the operation deepened the rupture in French-Israeli security relations.[1][7]
Sources
- 1Center for Israel Education, Israel Smuggles Sa’ar Missile Boats out of Cherbourg, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 2Office of the Historian, Historical Documents, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 3Jewish Virtual Library, Israel Military Intelligence: The Boats of Cherbourg, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 4Maariv, Deep Waters: How Naval Cooperation Between Germany and Israel Began, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 5Ynet, The Israelis Who Did “James Bond” and the Rare Documentation: The Missile-Boat Escape Operation in Stormy Seas, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 6The Jerusalem Post, The story of the 'stolen' missile boats Israel used in the Yom Kippur War, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 7Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, Tsilla Hershco, French-Israeli Security Cooperation in the Twenty-First Century, BESA Center, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 8The Times of Israel, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 9Jewish Virtual Library, Israeli Navy: The Navy Throughout Israel's Wars, accessed on October 31, 2026.
- 10Tradition, TRADITION’s 2021 Book Endorsements – Part II, accessed on October 31, 2026.
IsraelPedia Question & Answers
What was the Cherbourg Project?
The Cherbourg Project was an Israeli naval operation in December 1969 to bring five French-built vessels to Israel after a French arms embargo blocked their delivery. The boats left Cherbourg over Christmas and arrived at Haifa’s Kishon port on December 31, 1969. They were the remaining five vessels in a twelve-boat order intended for conversion into missile boats.
Why did France block the delivery of the Cherbourg boats?
France embargoed military equipment deliveries to Israel on January 6, 1969, affecting the five boats still at Cherbourg. The restrictions became comprehensive after Israel’s raid on Beirut airport, which followed an attack on an El Al aircraft in Athens in December 1968. Israel let construction and sea trials continue while hoping the embargo would be lifted before the boats were ready.
How did Israel arrange the release of the Cherbourg boats?
Israel used a commercial cover that presented the boats’ departure as a transfer to a third party, rather than a delivery to Israel. Norwegian shipping executive Martin Siem appeared to buy the vessels through STARBOAT S.A., with Norway listed as their nominal destination. French customs signed release papers on December 24, 1969; a second set of documents that reversed the apparent sale was not submitted to French authorities.
How did the Cherbourg boats reach Israel?
Five boats sailed from Cherbourg in single file during the Christmas period after a gale delayed their planned departure. Nearly 100 Israeli crewmen served aboard, and merchant ships positioned along the route provided fuel and assistance. The boats endured heavy seas, regrouped off Portugal after temporarily losing contact, and arrived at Haifa’s Kishon port on December 31, 1969.
What diplomatic consequences followed the Cherbourg Project?
The boats’ departure caused a diplomatic crisis between France and Israel. A French investigation concluded that Israel had purchased the vessels through an intermediary; two senior French officials were suspended, and Israel’s senior military representative was required to leave France. Limon was also required to leave, though accounts differ on whether he was expelled or recalled. The wider rupture contributed to Israel’s turn toward the United States as an ally and military supplier.
How were the Cherbourg boats used in the Yom Kippur War?
After reaching Israel, the five boats were fitted with Israeli-designed and manufactured Gabriel missiles, and their conversion, tactical development, and crew training took nearly four more years. They joined the seven boats delivered earlier in the missile-boat force deployed against Egyptian and Syrian naval units during the 1973 Yom Kippur War. Israeli boats sank Syrian and Egyptian missile boats, while reportedly evading all 54 Styx missiles fired at them during the war.